At 147-154, Prime for Prime, how would Floyd Mayweather Jr fair against these five Pro Boxers he beat in the past?

[BodyBagz]

He soundly outpointed Oscar

DLH was robbed in the rematch

[BodyBagz]

Pac had a shoulder injury and was already removed from his prime years.

You can obvious see Pac's arm about to fall off during the intro to this highlight clip.......

It's a miracle !!!!!

Neither guy was prime
Pac was KO'd twice by slobs, well before JMM flattened him.

[Haka]

Your obvious is not everybody's obvious, your perception of duck is guided by your bias its not guided by accurate checking, 5 people can see the same situation and you have 5 different versions of what happened, the rarest commodity on this planet today is Truth.

You guys always take the highlights of the JMM fight who came from 130 and extend your logic based on that. Never on the close fights with Cotto where he got beat up at times, Maidana which was a very close fight and Castillo which could have gone either way. Then you people never realize that Cotto Maidana and Castillo are good fighters but NOT great or special fighters in any given era. Yes he had success against 152 Canelo and 130 JMM but they are essentially counter fighters that tried to play a game of chicken against the creator of chicken boxing.

[Roadblock]

You guys always take the highlights of the JMM fight who came from 130 and extend your logic based on that. Never on the close fights with Cotto where he got beat up at times, Maidana which was a very close fight and Castillo which could have gone either way. Then you people never realize that Cotto Maidana and Castillo are good fighters but NOT great or special fighters in any given era. Yes he had success against 152 Canelo and 130 JMM but they are essentially counter fighters that tried to play a game of chicken against the creator of chicken boxing.

What is JMMs fight night weight, what was Floyds prime weight?

Beat up at times in a professional fight against HOF fighters lol , uhhhmmm Manny got put to sleep and beat up many times so I dont know what your point is here, its boxing every great had rough nights in the office but they still won.

Do you realize every great fighter has trouble with guys that on paper they shouldnt , many time's they dont get up fully for it , styles off night it happens, its boxing.

When you start talking chicken boxing you are stepping into fanboy territory and I suggest you have a go at the sport to see how ridicules these childish comments are.

[BodyBagz]

Pac lost how many times ?!?!?
He would lose twice as much if he had PBF/May exact resume.
On the other hand, not one Pac opponent would trouble May.
I don't even see May giving guys like Rios, HORN, Vargas, Algieri a shot.

[Haka]

Prime Bradley would be a top3 or top2 opponent on Floyd resume. Prime Bradley > Maidana

[FaustoGeraci]

Yawn. Lie after lie. Typical for you.

Manny chose not to fight. That is on him as a man. You look extremely weak and gay for defending that decision by placing blame on Floyd.

As I stated, when these men were in their primes they wouldn’t fight Floyd because he was high risk, low reward, despite the fact he was smaller than all but Manny.

You can’t change history so stop trying.

DLH would have fought anyone anytime. Vargas seemed to be the one exception for a while because of personal reasons. PBF and DLH just didn't have a chance because of different weight classes and different leaks.

[FaustoGeraci]

PBF/May was the perfect boxer.
Would go 0 in any era.
Brittle hands and all.

Robinson would have smashed him at 147.

[Haka]

What is JMMs fight night weight, what was Floyds prime weight?

Beat up at times in a professional fight against HOF fighters lol , uhhhmmm Manny got put to sleep and beat up many times so I dont know what your point is here, its boxing every great had rough nights in the office but they still won.

Do you realize every great fighter has trouble with guys that on paper they shouldnt , many time's they dont get up fully for it , styles off night it happens, its boxing.

When you start talking chicken boxing you are stepping into fanboy territory and I suggest you have a go at the sport to see how ridicules these childish comments are.

Floyd’s counter-focused, cautious style is ideally suited for counterpunchers, as it minimizes the volume of exchanges and allows him to control the pace. However, against relentless pressure fighters—who elevate the tempo and force more frequent exchanges—his strategy often results in closer contests due to the increased intensity and higher risk of engagement. This dynamic was evident in his closely contested fight with Maidana, who, while not a historically great fighter (as shown by his losses to Khan, Kotelnik and Alexander), was able to give Floyd significant trouble. This raises the question of why bouts against fighters like prime Mosley, prime Pacquiao, and Margarito—along with, to a lesser extent, Bradley—never materialized, as their aggressive styles would have presented similar challenges for Floyd.

[BodyBagz]

Prime Bradley would be a top3 or top2 opponent on Floyd resume. Prime Bradley > Maidana

Maidana > Ruslan