James Toney vs ?

[djtmal]

Right but yet he's never won a round against an elite HW so what exactly are you basing that on?

We have zero evidence that he could be competitive with the likes of Tua, or AJ.

I wouldn't consider either of those fighters elite either

[boola]

wow thats nice

[IronDanHamza]

I wouldn't consider either of those fighters elite either

That would be because you're an idiot.

[djtmal]

That would be because you're an idiot.

You know I am telling the truth, thats why you resort to name calling.

David Tua and Anthony Joshua elite fighters in what century.

Toney could take both those guys to deep water and drown them imo

[boola]

haha yeah he could take them both down

[IronDanHamza]

You know I am telling the truth, thats why you resort to name calling.

No you are just a straight up idiot. Every one on here knows that.

David Tua and Anthony Joshua elite fighters in what century.

Anthony Joshua is minimum Top 3 HW of the modern era, that's not even close to debatable. Unified Champion, beaten numerous Top 10 ranked HW's. That is the epitome of elite.

David Tua there's an argument because his is more based on potential as opposed to accomplishment but he was still a Top HW of his time.

Toney could take both those guys to deep water and drown them imo

Well yeah again because you're an idiot.

What could you possibly base this opinion on?

On what planet does James Toney, a guy who get's easily beaten by journeyman in his prime multiple times, that has not a single win over a Top HW somehow take the likes of AJ into deep water and drown him? Absolutely comical take.

[djtmal]

No you are

Neither one of those guys has beaten anyone on James Toney's skill level. Even the post Burger King version.
In prime or past it.
Not Joshua not Tua.

Just name one fighter who is remotely close.

Meanwhile, Toney has beaten, punchers, boxers, and everything in between. Has more fights than those dudes has wins put together.

Good to see you came to your senses and don't want to debate Tua being mediocre at best, because you would be truly delusional, and you take Joshua out of this mediocre era of heavys he's in and he couldn't get past the lazy, fridge in the bedroom version of Rid**** Bowe.

Hell, he would go life and death with Carl The Truth Williams. Tony "TNT" Tubbs. Buster Mathis would smoke that dude.

Dudes a Eurobum.

[IronDanHamza]

Neither one of those guys has beaten anyone on James Toney's skill level. In prime or past it. Not Joshua not Tua.

Just name one fighter who is remotely close.

Meanwhile, Toney has beaten, punchers, boxers, and everything in between. Has more fights than those dudes has wins put together.

Good to see you came to your senses and don't want to debate Tua being mediocre at best, because you would be truly delusional, and you take Joshua out of this mediocre era of heavys he's in and he couldn't get past the lazy, fridge in the bedroom version of Rid**** Bowe.

Hell, he would go life and death with Carl The Truth Williams

Not at Heavyweight he hasn't.

You bring up Carl Williams like James Toney could ever be competitive with the likes of Williams

We have ZERO evidence that Toney can beat a Top HW fighter. Zero.

AJ is one of the Top HW's of his time, unified champion. The idea of Toney even being competitive with someone of that description is laughable and not based in reality.

[djtmal]

Not at

You can't name one fighter that either one of those guys beat, thats on Toney's skill level.

Toney has beaten guys exactly like those bums.

Tua's always been a c fighter at best, and the minute they put Joshua in with somebody who can hit back, he hasn't been the same since.

[djtmal]

AJ is one of the Top HW's of his time, unified champion.

He's a bum. A Eurobum at that.

Would barely crack top ten in any other era.