Margarito beats Cotto 10 times out of 10.

[Ether]

With or without plaster.

[Peek_A_Boo]

EPIC FAIL of a thread!!!!!!!

[MANGLER]

Depends on whether or not SSM destroyed his chin. If Marg's beard remains in tact, I agree wit this. Cotto can't beat him. If his chin is gone, Marg will lose. He can't fight his kinda fight without that reinforced jaw.

[Mersey]

I think Marg could beat Cotto again too. Probably not 10/10 tho.

[Mr. Ryan]

Depends on whether or not SSM destroyed his chin. If Marg's beard remains in tact, I agree wit this. Cotto can't beat him. If his chin is gone, Marg will lose. He can't fight his kinda fight without that reinforced jaw.

License revocation or not, I think Margarito is damaged goods. Shane Mosley should've been arrested and charged with aggravated assault; or given a trophy for most one-sided ass whoopings.

[Spray_resistant]

Probably could beat Cotto 10 out of 10, Margarito is all wrong for Cotto. Cotto likes to be the bully and is taken out of his element against Tony, Cotto doesn't fight well when forced to be defensive. Margarito/with/without plaster > Cotto every time.

[$partacus]

Cotto would just get overwhelmed again if he faced Margarito.

[onetwopunch]

I dont know, no question Margarito is a horrible matchup for Cotto, becuase of his style, chin and reach advantages, but Cotto was fighting extremely well, considering he wasnt going to the body which he should of. Minus the plaster Cotto might of been able to last longer and possibly pull out a UD

[Freddy Krueger]

Margarito was exposed against ssm, did you know that Margarito landed about 110 punches on Mosley and none of them had an affect on Mosley? And Compbox said Mosley landed about 178 punches on Margarito, and all those punches had an affect.

110 punches that didn't phase Mosley one bit, wow Margarito really does punch like a little school girl without the plaster to help him out.

[$partacus]

Margarito was exposed against ssm, did you know that Margarito landed about 110 punches on Mosley and none of them had an affect on Mosley? And Compbox said Mosley landed about 178 punches on Margarito, and all those punches had an affect.

110 punches that didn't phase Mosley one bit, wow Margarito really does punch like a little school girl without the plaster to help him out.

That might be because Margarito isn't a big puncher he wins fights by wearing his opponent down and Mosley has got one of the best chins in boxing.