Do you consider JMM as an ATG???

[Piper the Great]

no.. b/c his biggest fights are a loss & a draw. & mabye a loss to floyd.

[trickshot]

NO jmm is not an ATG,

JMM is a great win for Pac and good addition to Pac's legacy. but he is not an ATG.

[S.G.]

It's tough but I think his bad luck in his two fights with Pacquiao prevent him from ATG status for now. If they'd given him his deserved W in the second fight then he would be an all time great in my eyes

Close fights and robberies are generally lost with time, while that official W is permanent

If he manages to beat Floyd then he's ATG. If he loses, we'll see what happens.

[hammerhiem]

60-70 range probably, great career all things considered.

[Bushidō]

ATG not sure. Depends who else you got in your ATG. HE is one of best right now though

[yeks]

the point to the comparison is, both Ali and Frietas were DONE. get it?

all boxers aren't done until they are beaten.. lol

Pac's opponent for instance were all DONE in the eyes of the haters.. you see what i mean?

[The_Demon]

atg top 100

[Pullcounter]

lets wait for boxer's careers to be over before we call them ATG

[trickshot]

all boxers aren't done until they are beaten.. lol

Pac's opponent for instance were all DONE in the eyes of the haters.. you see what i mean?

lmfao!! easy there crabcake.