If Mayweather fights Shane you wil give him no credit.

[UnDeniable]

So you will give him credit for beating a smaller guy than Mosley or Cotto?

I will give him credit if he beats mosley or Cotto, not manny.

Manny is seen as near unbeatable atm

Casual fans are obcessed with him and every poll on this site has manny winning

he is the most popular fighter on the planet and seeing mr.unpopular Mayweather knock Manny out would bring a smile to my face

A win over Manny is the bigger win by far

[Pullcounter]

To be fair, Mosley is past his prime

Prime Mosley would have beaten Cotto and would have destroyed Mayorga

The majority of Floyd fans want a Pac fight because it adds a prime ATG to his resume and shuts up the pinoys on the site

Only ricans would be left to ***** and moan

but you gotta admit, all the ****-talking floyd and his fans do against mosley, doesn't help the situation.

if they want credit, they should be complementary towards mosley instead of dissing him.

[jose1418]

To be fair, Mosley is past his prime

Prime Mosley would have beaten Cotto and would have destroyed Mayorga

The majority of Floyd fans want a Pac fight because it adds a prime ATG to his resume and shuts up the pinoys on the site

Only ricans would be left to ***** and moan

If it's so easy for floyd to beat Cotto and mosley why he don't clear that division and stop calling smaller guys?

A fight with Pac will give him a lot of money, no credit.

[jose1418]

Manny is seen as near unbeatable atm

Casual fans are obcessed with him and every poll on this site has manny winning

he is the most popular fighter on the planet and seeing mr.unpopular Mayweather knock Manny out would bring a smile to my face

A win over Manny is the bigger win by far

So this is only for your satisfaction, not if floyd get credit or not, right?

[UnDeniable]

So this is only for your satisfaction, not if floyd get credit or not, right?

When people look back 50 years from now, Pac would be more impressive on a resume than Mosley and Cotto

Floyd is closer to Pac sizewise than he is to Cotto or Mosley

If Shane or Cotto beat Floyd should they get no credit because Floyd is smaller

Pac when fighting - 148lbs

Floyd when fighting - 148lbs

Mosley when fighting - 155+ lbs

Cotto when fighting - 155+ lbs

[Bhopreign]

Floyd has never gotten credit for any fight so nothing will change. Because of being constantly criticized his whole career, Floyd acts the way he does to piss those people off while making millions from them.

What the detractors say:

Hernandez - Old as dirt was on his way out.

Manfredy - Ref stopped the fight way too soon.

Castillo I - Floyd lost

Castillo II - Scores closer than first fight when Castillo won first fight

Corrales - Corrales was going to jail, weight drained and his mind was messed up.

Gatti - Not too skilled, Gatti had lost many times before.

Judah - Had just lost to Baldomir, a journeyman.

Baldomir - Career journeyman who got lucky.

Oscar - He was old and Floyd barely got a SD.

Hatton - Hatton had no business at 147 in the first place, Collazo showed that.

Marquez - He just moved to 135 and Floyd bringing him to welterweight?

[Scott9945]

Facts:

Shane lost to Cotto.

Shane is 37 years old.

Shane is past his prime.



So shut the **** up with the Floyd should fight Shane crap.

Because he wont get credit

Bernard Hopkins lost to Calzaghe

Bernard Hopkins is 44 years old.

Bernard Hopkins is past his prime.

So are you saying that Chad Dawson (or anyone else at 175) wouldn't get credit for beating him?

Mayweather fans are so sensitive.

[UnDeniable]

Bernard Hopkins lost to Calzaghe

Bernard Hopkins is 44 years old.

Bernard Hopkins is past his prime.

So are you saying that Chad Dawson (or anyone else at 175) wouldn't get credit for beating him?

Mayweather fans are so sensitive.

Chad is a popular fighter, Floyd isn't

The fact remains that people wanted to see Floyd against Judah, DLH and Hatton

and yet somehow he still hasn't fought anyone, if Floyd beats Cotto, Pac and Shane he will still be accused of ducking

[jeg77]

This is true the same thing happens with Cotto. They praise Mayweather way to much and esteem him as unbeatable against guys who really have a chance !

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

He would get credit for taking a step in the right direction by starting to clear out his own division.

Co sigN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1