If Pac Beats Ricky, but JMM beat PBF who's # 1?

[loui_ludwig]

It doesn't matter if JMM becomes P4P #1 if he beats Mayweather, Pac still has a win over Marquez. Or you can make that 2 wins if the error in the 1st fight was corrected.

[koboy]

It doesn't matter if JMM becomes P4P #1 if he beats Mayweather, Pac still has a win over Marquez. Or you can make that 2 wins if the error in the 1st fight was corrected.

Can we not make this about the dispute over who won their 1st 2 fights. I think that's been done alot here already. Let's take the official results and decide who the P4P king will be if both Pac #1 and JMM # 2 wins their respective fights. Now who is it going to be for you with this scenario?

[Ido]

edit nevermind.

[Pullcounter]

I'm going to say JMM here.

pac is still #1 even if jmm beats pbf because pbf is coming off a layoff and coming down in weight; not to mention that pac already beat JMM 2x.

[loui_ludwig]

Can we not make this about the dispute over who won their 1st 2 fights. I think that's been done alot here already. Let's take the official results and decide who the P4P king will be if both Pac #1 and JMM # 2 wins their respective fights. Now who is it going to be for you with this scenario?

I would say Pac but i would leave it to the Ring mag and other boxing media outlets outthere(except for boxrec).

[THRILLA77]

Marquez for sure

[Chups]

It's up to the most recognized authority in P4P rankings, which is The RING.

[koboy]

This would have been easier with a poll, wouldn't it?

How you make one?

[dibzvincent143]

it would still be pacquiao.because if he beats hatton,he will become the first to have 4-lineal real-claim titles in 6 weight divisions.also pacquiao has beaten marquez.

[koboy]

It's up to the most recognized authority in P4P rankings, which is The RING.

I'm asking you what you think. So who is it gonna be?