If Pac Beats Ricky, but JMM beat PBF who's # 1?

[Kevin Jesus]

Counter question, where would you rank PBF if he beats Marquez?

[RL_GMA]

Pacquiao

Just because Floyd is who he is doesn't just put JMM over a guy he's fought twice and never beaten. Floyd retired which changed the landscape of the P4P list. If anything it'll make the trilogy into a Mega Event than the previous 2 fights.

If Shane beat were to beat Floyd if Pac doesn't fight him, would it be fair to put Mosley over Pacquiao being Pacquiao had already beaten Hatton who was undefeated at 140?

[nujabes77]

pacquiao, you gotta beat the best to be the best

marquez hasn't done that


but if he KTFO mayweather not a ud, i'd probably make him 1

[koboy]

Questions like these are left unanswered. 1 victory, is not enough to disregard previous, recent accomplishments. Its better to go the 3rd showdown to simply settle, who deserves the recognitions.

But before you do the 3rd showdown, you still have to rank them , right. So who do you think is going to be ranked #1 before they settle for a 3rd fight?

[nujabes77]

Counter question, where would you rank PBF if he beats Marquez?

i would say 2... you gotta beat the best to be the best

[-Mustang-]

Those are some pretty big IF'S...

but since mayweater > hatton , and JMM and Pac are very close at p4p 1-2 rankings...
that JMM jumps over pac

sooo... JMM

[Jose Rizal]

JMM should be p4p no. 1 in that scenario.

Floyd's just too big a name for a victim even with the layoff of more than a year, but a win is highly improbable for JMM anyway.

[elfag]

If JMM actually beat PBF at anywhere from 140-147 he is ahead.

I think Pac-Hatton is a close fight but I dont give JMM a big chance at all, that would definitely be a huge upset.

[koboy]

Pacquiao

Just because Floyd is who he is doesn't just put JMM over a guy he's fought twice and never beaten. Floyd retired which changed the landscape of the P4P list. If anything it'll make the trilogy into a Mega Event than the previous 2 fights.

If Shane beat were to beat Floyd if Pac doesn't fight him, would it be fair to put Mosley over Pacquiao being Pacquiao had already beaten Hatton who was undefeated at 140?

Shane's not # 2 and he won't be moving up. I think JMM moving up and beating PBF, a former undefeated # 1, is a bigger accomplishment than Shane beating PBF.

[MANGLER]

Pac is #1 til he gets beat. Mr boat buyer ain't in the rankings anymore.