Important Question.

[Darkstar]

Since Jones v.s. Calzaghe has become a reality.

We know that a large contingent of people who in fact are avid calzaghe fans, are quick to question Jones' career and claim he's a "fraud".

Now the time is upon us, and the same people who are so happy he's out of the P4P lists are now faced with a serious dilemma.

Jones has a good chance at beating the number 2 P4P fighter in the sport.

(^hahahahahaha@ the #2 rating I'd never believe that myself)

I mean according to them.......Calzaghe is the second best fighter no?

If Diaz would have beat Pacquiao, would he have took Pacquiaos top 3 P4p spot? No, same should go for Jones.

He has done nothing of late to even be considered a p4p fighter:

He let the smaller shot Trinidad go the distance with him. (his best win in years)
Beat Anthony Hansaw? Then Prince Badi Ajamu?? Not exactly anything that is p4p about that.
Tarver- LOSS
Glen Johnson- LOSS: Got knocked out badly.
Tarver- LOSS: Got knocked out badly.

Even if Jones were to win he shouldnt be anywhere near a top 15 p4p list. A Calzaghe win for him would be great. Most likey one of the best fighters hes ever been in with. If he were to win it would be one of his biggest wins by far(what does that tell you?lol) But the P4P list is for fighters who consistantly win and against good competion.

[Run]

RWK, Calzaghe has been #1 in a lot of people's minds for a long time. Eventually you're just going to have to accept that Joe is one of the greatest fighters of his generation. behind Roy, sure, but far ahead of Hopkins and probably even ahead of Toney.

No he's not. That's just ****ing ridiculous.

He lacks the career defining wins, sorry. He has 2 wins and they were against what we now know was a terribly green, overrated fighter.............and a severely overrated Dane who is pampered in his own circuit and became a P4P fighter based on fighting Anthony Mundine.

Hopkins was 100 years old.



| |

[Run]

If Diaz would have beat Pacquiao, would he have took Pacquiaos top 3 P4p spot? No, same should go for Jones.

Even remotely comparing Roy Jones to David Diaz is just impossible.

I see where you went with that, but No.



| |

[Sweet Pea 50]

I got 10k on RJJ. Any takers?

[Del Coqui]

DEFINITELY, especially if he beats him in convincingly.