Originally posted by slicksouthpaw16
View Post
I don't agree with your analysis about Hopkins by the way. Hopkins is a fighter who fights in a way that he controls the pace. Hopkins doesn't need his opponent to play into his hands in order to win the fight. It is incumbent on the opponent to find a way to get out of the Hopkins deep freeze. Dawson could do it, but a southpaw's nightmare is a stellar straight right counter. Hopkins has the best in the business. That being said, I am not sold that Hopkins beats him either. I just don't think we have enough information yet on whether Dawson could beat Hopkins. Dawson needs more experience though before he has a prayer of really clearly beating Hopkins. He might win a razor-close fight now, but he needs more ring experience if he really wants to make Hopkins look bad.
The Calzaghe fight would be an interesting challenge. They are both fast. Calzaghe would be coming up, so you are probably right about Dawson having the edge in power. The advantages for Calzaghe is his work rate, and his adaptability. He made a very technically gifted fighter in Kessler look pretty bad at times late in the fight. If Dawson finds a way to make sure that Calzaghe doesn't "spoil" Dawson's game plan, then he beats Calzaghe. If he can't find a way to do that, he is in trouble. The problem for Dawson is he doesn't have a blue print to work off of for the Calzaghe challenge, so no one has ever figured out how to get around Joe's workrate and his ability to get there first. There is also the problem of Joe Calzaghe having insane adaptability. Once again, I have no idea who would win the fight, because I am not comfortable making a call on this fight because I don't have nearly enough information on Dawson to make an educated guess about a fight between him and a very established, very good champion.
No idea about Erdei again, so I'm not going to dive into that.
And I think it is a stretch to call Adamek a badass at this point. Yes, he was 31-0, but who had he fought that was worth talking about? I'm not saying he's a bad fighter, because he is not, but it is a stretch to call him a badass that truly tested how good Dawson is.
Like I said, Dawson has proved that he is a good fighter. He needs someone great to prove whether he is great or not.
Comment