The Top 20 All-Time Greatest P4P List

[CodeBreaker]

Lol at people not including Muhammad Ali just to look smart and cool lmao

[GhostofDempsey]

Lol at people not including Muhammad Ali just to look smart and cool lmao

It’s a P4P list, not a Heavyweight list. Ali made too many mistakes that he could get away with against slow heavyweights, not against other weight classes.

[Canelo and GGG]

It’s a P4P list, not a Heavyweight list. Ali made too many mistakes that he could get away with against slow heavyweights, not against other weight classes.

Problem with your statement is that heavies fight like they do cuse they are HWs ,ofc Ali would be diffrent fighter if he was mw or lw , Whitaker would not fight like he did if he woulld be HW ,it makes no sense man.

[GhostofDempsey]

Problem with your statement is that heavies fight like they do cuse they are HWs ,ofc Ali would be diffrent fighter if he was mw or lw , Whitaker would not fight like he did if he woulld be HW ,it makes no sense man.

Of course it makes sense. If Whitaker was a heavyweight he would look a lot like Dempsey. Ali would be more like Hamed and end up getting worked over by someone with superior skills. P4P means you take the skills a fighter has and put him in another weight class, you don’t get to assume he would be a different fighter and train differently.

[QueensburyRules]

Problem with your statement is that heavies fight like they do cuse they are HWs ,ofc Ali would be diffrent fighter if he was mw or lw , Whitaker would not fight like he did if he woulld be HW ,it makes no sense man.

- -Sorta like U being different if U was a girl.

Or an acorn!

[Canelo and GGG]

Of course it makes sense. If Whitaker was a heavyweight he would look a lot like Dempsey. Ali would be more like Hamed and end up getting worked over by someone with superior skills. P4P means you take the skills a fighter has and put him in another weight class, you don’t get to assume he would be a different fighter and train differently.

Or he would be more like Roy Jones junior ,its just guessing ,Imagine Floyd at HW with his shoulder roll vs fighters with reach llike Fury or Wilder ,some styles work becuse of your physical attributes (size ,reach etc) ,and they would train diffrent ,you train to maximize your strengths.

[Canelo and GGG]

- -Sorta like U being different if U was a girl.

Or an acorn!

exactly , thats my point

[QueensburyRules]

exactly , thats my point

- -And that's why U post here, but we don't know if U a girl or an acorn.

Well?

[QueensburyRules]

- -The new "predictive fantasy fights" All Time Boxrec p4p top 25.

It is not popular within that format of overseers:

[Rusty Tromboni]

It’s a P4P list, not a Heavyweight list. Ali made too many mistakes that he could get away with against slow heavyweights, not against other weight classes.

Well said, also makes guys like Frazier and Fury look that much more impressive.