Trivia: NON-HOFers who fought at least 12 HOFers

[Bundana]

I can only guess at some maybes without massive research. Can you at least give us a hint and tell how many there are in total, or do you know? I assume you do.

I think The Houge brothers and Chuck Wiggins could easily be on such a list if not HOFers themselves. Another guy could be Gus Lesnevich. I don't know the HOF very well.

Wiggins is an excellent guess - and at 11 (if I have counted correctly) is just one HOFer short of making the list!

I believe, at least 3 men are on the list. I say "at least", as I can't promise, I haven't overlooked someone!

[Willie Pep 229]

Good try, nevertheless... though Jim Driscoll looks a bit out of place here!

Jim Driscoll isn't 'a bit out of place' (that's polite of you) he is down right wrong.

I was jumping from page to page trying to find possibilities, and must have been on a different fighter's page when I thought I was on Porky Dan's.

Just plain wrong.

So I am not clear. Does Porky Dan have 12?

If so I'll keep looking?

[Bundana]

Jim Driscoll isn't 'a bit out of place' (that's polite of you) he is down right wrong.

I was jumping from page to page trying to find possibilities, and must have been on a different fighter's page when I thought I was on Porky Dan's.

Just plain wrong.

So I am not clear. Does Porky Dan have 12?

If so I'll keep looking?

Not counting Driscoll, Porky Dan only has the 9 you listed.

One of the guys we're looking for was quite prominent in his time: He never fought for a world title, but was Top-10 ranked by The Ring over several years... and of the 12 HOFers he met, he holds wins against 7 of them (record for a non-HOFer!).