Checked Lists Ali Can Be Considered For

[Slugfester]

1. Best Jab Ever ✓
2. Hardest Punching Heavyweight
3. Best Heavyweight Chin ✓
4. Best Heavyweight Ever ✓
5. Fastest Heavyweight Hands ✓
6. Fastest Heavyweight Feet ✓
7. Best Left Hook
8. Best Body Puncher
9. Best Ring General ✓
10. Best Combination Puncher ✓
11. Most Well Conditioned ✓
12. Best PP Ever ✓
13. Durability ✓
14. Psychological Warfare ✓
15. Killer Instinct ✓
16. Best Pure Boxer

[markusmod]

1. Best Jab Ever ✓
2. Hardest Punching Heavyweight
3. Best Heavyweight Chin ✓
4. Best Heavyweight Ever ✓
5. Fastest Heavyweight Hands ✓
6. Fastest Heavyweight Feet ✓
7. Best Left Hook
8. Best Body Puncher
9. Best Ring General ✓
10. Best Combination Puncher ✓
11. Most Well Conditioned ✓
12. Best PP Ever ✓
13. Durability ✓
14. Psychological Warfare ✓
15. Killer Instinct ✓
16. Best Pure Boxer

Do you think he had faster heavyweight hands than Byrd or Jones?

[Slugfester]

Do you think he had faster heavyweight hands than Byrd or Jones?

Jones carried a juice bag.

[Incapable]

Yes all the above. No one ever comes near the greatest.

[QueensburyRules]

1. Best Jab Ever ✓
2. Hardest Punching Heavyweight
3. Best Heavyweight Chin ✓
4. Best Heavyweight Ever ✓
5. Fastest Heavyweight Hands ✓
6. Fastest Heavyweight Feet ✓
7. Best Left Hook
8. Best Body Puncher
9. Best Ring General ✓
10. Best Combination Puncher ✓
11. Most Well Conditioned ✓
12. Best PP Ever ✓
13. Durability ✓
14. Psychological Warfare ✓
15. Killer Instinct ✓
16. Best Pure Boxer

1. Best Jab Ever x
2. Hardest Punching Heavyweight
3. Best Heavyweight Chin x
4. Best Heavyweight Ever x
5. Fastest Heavyweight Hands x
6. Fastest Heavyweight Feet ✓
7. Best Left Hook
8. Best Body Puncher
9. Best Ring General x
10. Best Combination Puncher x
11. Most Well Conditioned x
12. Best PP Ever x
13. Durability ✓
14. Psychological Warfare ✓
15. Killer Instinct x
16. Best Pure Boxer

- - You checked 12 where as you can see I Xed 9 leaving Ali with 3.

[JAB5239]

Best combination puncher goes to Louis. Killer instict could be argued amongst several men more suited than Ali.

[Willie Pep 229]

1. Best Jab Ever x
2. Hardest Punching Heavyweight
3. Best Heavyweight Chin x
4. Best Heavyweight Ever x
5. Fastest Heavyweight Hands x
6. Fastest Heavyweight Feet ✓
7. Best Left Hook
8. Best Body Puncher
9. Best Ring General x
10. Best Combination Puncher x
11. Most Well Conditioned x
12. Best PP Ever x
13. Durability ✓
14. Psychological Warfare ✓
15. Killer Instinct x
16. Best Pure Boxer

- - You checked 12 where as you can see I Xed 9 leaving Ali with 3.

Agree --> except maybe Ring General. If we are talking just HWs I am not sure I can think of a better one, maybe Tunney?

If it is all weights, then there are more than a few above him.

I wonder if the OP's inconsistent categories list between HWs only and all-weights is deliberate?

[markusmod]

Jones carried a juice bag.

It didn't help him last Saturday!

[Slugfester]

Do you think he had faster heavyweight hands than Byrd or Jones?

I said lists he could be considered for. Jones? Was Stanley Ketchel a heavyweight too?

[markusmod]

Agree --> except maybe Ring General. If we are talking just HWs I am not sure I can think of a better one, maybe Tunney?

If it is all weights, then there are more than a few above him.

I wonder if the OP's inconsistent categories list between HWs only and all-weights is deliberate?

Good points