How good is Floyd Mayweather's resume as a ATG?

[elfag]

its way up there.

you know how many guys they were saying would beat him, got their chance, lost and then all the excuses made why they lost. and floyd gave weight advantages to every single one of them. the ONE time floyd fought a smaller guy in JMM they cried about it. Floyd came off a 18 month layoff to fight like the #3 p4p guy in his one and only fight against a smaller guy and they made a huge deal out of it while praising weight bullies like a margarito or hatton type.

[elfag]

people will hype Marciano to the moon when 40 of his 49 wins were random factory workers and farmers.

Marciano was still fighting guys with losing records in his 33 and 34th fight but people will claim he has a better record than mayweather out of pure hate. then when mayweather beat Mcgreggor at 40 years old they will say that fight doesnt count, it doesnt mean he beat marciano's record, but the 180 pound guy with 57 losses that marciano fought in his 29th pro fight, well that counts towards his 49 undefeated wins but mcgreggor doesnt count lmao.

[elfag]

Guys like you lie about the condition of his opposition.

example, you made a thread asking Floyd to fight Shane next. You didn’t say Shane was shot. He fought him 4 months after that. You picked Shane to win. Floyd won. You claimed Shane was shot. You denied making the thread until IrondanHamza found it and exposed you.

You’re so very bitter that Floyd beat Manny, you will lie like you did above.

Can’t have a reasonable discussion with someone like you. Maybe one day you will get over the loss, stop lying, and show some integrity.

lol this. I been on various boxing boards for 20 years. all the same guys talking **** these days are the same ones picking floyd to lose over and over again. these guys picked him to lose against hatton, cotto, mosley, pacquaio, all of them. then each and every time its an excuse, oh no he was shot, oh it wasnt his prime weight, this and that, but they were picking floyd to lose pre fight. then these same guys want to hype up someone like GGG with wins over steve rolls and various Sergio leftovers like martin murray.

they'll make up all kinds of excuses to trivialize any win. say floyd-canelo floyd gave up 15 pounds and 13 years, he fought a 15 pound heavier guy at age 36 years old and its still not enough, they are mad that floyd didnt come out of retirement for a rematch in his 40s to lose at 168, that is all they want to see.

its very clear floyd is up there with the ATG in terms of resume or head to head. You can argue your preference for who is the best but if he is not at minimum in your top 10 it is just hate clouding your judgement.

[Marchegiano]

GOAT of course, duh.

[Santa_]

Great resume. Lots of big names on his record. The 152 Canelo win stands out most IMO. Canelo wasn't near his prime but it's still a better win than Floyd's over the hill wins (Oscar, Pac, Mosley).

The Corrales, Castillo and Hatton victories are his prime fighter standouts. Good wins there. I also enjoyed the Victor Ortiz beatdown Lmao.

[Marchegiano]

people will hype Marciano to the moon when 40 of his 49 wins were random factory workers and farmers.

Marciano was still fighting guys with losing records in his 33 and 34th fight but people will claim he has a better record than mayweather out of pure hate. then when mayweather beat Mcgreggor at 40 years old they will say that fight doesnt count, it doesnt mean he beat marciano's record, but the 180 pound guy with 57 losses that marciano fought in his 29th pro fight, well that counts towards his 49 undefeated wins but mcgreggor doesnt count lmao.

One of them was his brother ... I think, tbh I can't remember if it was an ams or pro fight but I know Rocco got his baby brother to play boxing for at least an ams fight to pad his record.


Tiger Ted Lowry always felt like he won, btw. Not only did Marciano fight a man with some 57ish losses in Rock's 30th fight (It is 30, recount bro) but he struggled with that jabroni to the point some, including said jabroni, felt like Ted had won.

This was a rematch to an earlier fight that had ended similarly. Rocky got the win but some folks said it was a robbery. Ted believed if he was white he'd've been given the W. Rocky said, after the rematch, folks expect a knockout when he fights but he couldn't KO Ted if he had 100 goes so the rematch was the last attempt.

Just saying, if the point was to bury a guy you chose the right opponent. Too bad then it took a Marciano fan to tell you all about the details that make that fight even worse than you thought by just looking at boxrec. That sounds like a criticism, I didn't mean it like that. I see all the posts, I get the time put into each, I just think had you taken more time you could have written a good burial and as a fan I see this dude get buried all the time, just not very well. Just BS like this ... but dis guy on him record not so great doe ... c'mon guy, you can get a little deeper bro.




I wonder why you chose to pick on Marciano. No one likes Marciano but me and Anthony Who TF been hyping Rock what I ain't noticed? Apples maybe?

[djtmal]

example, you made a thread asking Floyd to fight Shane next. You didn’t say Shane was shot. He fought him 4 months after that..

brian kenny put floyd on the spot about mosley and floyd said mosley wasn't a draw. that was his justification for cherrypicking a lightweight

dude it took floyd mayweather almost 15 years to finally fight shane mosley and it wasn't even immediately after shane beat margarito (his last hurrah imo) it was almost two years later get your lies straight

mosley was 38 years old and shopworn. thats not even debatable.

in what world is beating a 38 year old, once great fighter a great win. floyd couldn't even put the worst version of mosley on the canvas.

you keep bringing up shane mosley like it was some prime, all time great win for floyd mayweather, when in reality it was another stalled fight to maximize the earning potential.

same thing with Cotto and Manny

somebody get this dude some kleenex between him and Roadblock I don't know who does more boohooing about floyd's manufactured resume...

[djtmal]

His resume is full of guys you and others picked to beat him.

lol.

Shopworn Manny Cotto 38 year old Mosley
Past prime Gatti rip
Ortiz
Carlos Slow Come Forward Baldymir
Lightweight Marquez
Guerrero
Madonna 2x
Berto
0-0 Conor McGregor
120 Japanese Kickboxer

Yeah Mayweather was a huge underdog in all of those fights.

[djtmal]

Guys like you lie about the condition of his opposition.

.

0-0 Conor McGregor was in peak form i suppose

[djtmal]

people will hype Marciano to the moon when 40 of his 49 wins were random factory workers and farmers.

Marciano was still fighting guys with losing records in his 33 and 34th fight but people will claim he has a better record than mayweather out of pure hate. then when mayweather beat Mcgreggor at 40 years old they will say that fight doesnt count, it doesnt mean he beat marciano's record, but the 180 pound guy with 57 losses that marciano fought in his 29th pro fight, well that counts towards his 49 undefeated wins but mcgreggor doesnt count lmao.

Man there is no way in the world you get off justifying a so called best ever fighter, even getting in the ring with a 0-0 guy who put on boxing gloves a month or two prior

Thats like the Jordan led Dream Team, beating up on Japan. S**t don't even count.