Where is Miguel Cotto ranked in everyones P4P list?

[El Dominicano]

Honestly, I still have him in my Top 5. He has a GREAT resume. I ask this question because Cotto has been moved way down on peoples P4P list.

My Top 5 would be
1. Pacman
2. JMM I had him winning the 2nd fight against Pac BUT his resume can't compare with Pac's CLOSE but NO

3. Calzaghe = ................

4. Margarito = Beat undefeated Kermit Cintron TWICE, Clottey and Cotto.

5. Cotto = He beat an undefeated Ricardo Torres who was a REALLY hard puncher, He beat undefeated Paulie Malignaggi, undefeated Carlos Quintana, He beat Zab Judah and SSM...a fighter I thought he wouldn't stand a chance against...I remember CORRECTLY, ALOT...AND I mean a whole LOT of people pick SSM to beat Cotto. These fighters aren't big names but he also beat Carlos Maussa and Kelson Pinto who were also undefeated. I made this thread because alot of people have B-Hop and and Pavlik on top of him. I'm a HUGE B-Hop fan but believe his days are done. In my opinion Pavlik's resume doesn't compare to Cotto's.

Note: Coming up....you usually look for a fighter with a BAD RECORD just to build yourself. Cotto didn't do that and took ALOT of risks. He deserves RESPECT. If he isn't affected MENTALLY by his lost to Margarito then...he has a bright future ahead of him and he is ONLY 27. He will be able to accomplish much more

[krispy kreme]

He is still top 10, but I think number 5 is where he should be right now.

[AntonTheMeh]

boxing is a sport of fleeting love.they love you one minute, they hate you the next.
we'll see what he's made of.margarito is definitely a better fighter than alot of people (including me) thought.he's just slow.bout time he got his due, and considering rafa and izzy are there cause of each other,he aint that far away from the top 5.

[ACHlLLES]

I still rank him better then Margarito, but I'm biased because I don't like Margarito fighting at WelterWeight

[Joe2608]

He's not in my top 10 until he proves he can come back from this defeat, he got beat up badly by Margarito.

[Pullcounter]

Honestly, I still have him in my Top 5. He has a GREAT resume. I ask this question because Cotto has been moved way down on peoples P4P list.

My Top 5 would be
1. Pacman
2. JMM I had him winning the 2nd fight against Pac BUT his resume can't compare with Pac's CLOSE but NO

3. Calzaghe = ................

4. Margarito = Beat undefeated Kermit Cintron TWICE, Clottey and Cotto.

5. Cotto = He beat undefeated and a really hard puncher in Ricardo Torres, He beat undefeated Paul Malignaggi, undefeated Carlos Quintana, He beat Zab Judah and SSM a fighter I thought he wouldn't stand a chance against...I remember CORRECTLY, ALOT...AND I mean a whole LOT of people pick SSM to beat Cotto. These fighters aren't big names but he also beat Carlos Maussa and Kelson Pinto who were also undefeated. I made this thread because alot of people have B-Hop and and Pavlik on top of him.

Note: Coming up....you usually look for a fighter with a BAD RECORD just to build yourself. Cotto didn't do that and took ALOT of risks. He deserves RESPECT. He has a bright future ahead of him and he is ONLY 27. He will be able to accomplish much more

margarito and cotto have no business being 4 or 5. Mijares, Vasquez, R. Marquez, and Calderon are all better than both of them.

[S.G.]

10th... one place behind Margarito (i'm reluctant to include Margarito to be honest, but he beat a P4P'er so he gets to stay there until he loses or someone pushes him off there)

my top 10 pound for pound for anyone interested:
1) Manny Pacquiao
2) Juan Manuel Marquez
3) Joe Calzaghe
4) Israel Vasquez
5) Bernard Hopkins (he's staying up there until Pavlik beats him, because he arguably beat another P4P'er in Calzaghe)
6) Rafael Marquez
7) Kelly Pavlik
8) Cristian Mijares
9) Antonio Margarito
10) Miguel Cotto

i find it very difficult to get the top 10 in order when taking into consideration skills vs. records and recent results

[WLAD OWNS]

My top 10 p4p list

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Joe Calzaghe
3. Juan Manuel Marquez
4. Israel Vazquez
5. Kelly Pavlik
6. Antonio Margarito
7. Christian Mijares
8. Wladimir Klitschko
9. Bernard Hopkins
10. Miguel Cotto

Cotto's impressive resume keeps him in the top 10

[sylvestersweet]

1. Juan Manuel Marquez
2. Manny Pacquiao
3. Kelly Pavlik
4. Antonio Margarito
5. Israel Vasquez
6. Cristan Mijares
7. Paul Williams
8. Arthur Abraham
9. Joe Calzaghe
10. Rafael Marquez
11. Ivan Calderon
12. Miguel Cotto
13. Ricky Hatton
14. Jermain Taylor
15. Joshua Clottey
16. Nate Campbell
17. Juan Manuel Lopez
18. Antonio Tarver
19. Carl Froch
20. Juan Diaz

[Sage84]

10th... one place behind Margarito (i'm reluctant to include Margarito to be honest, but he beat a P4P'er so he gets to stay there until he loses or someone pushes him off there)

my top 10 pound for pound for anyone interested:
1) Manny Pacquiao
2) Juan Manuel Marquez
3) Joe Calzaghe
4) Israel Vasquez
5) Bernard Hopkins (he's staying up there until Pavlik beats him, because he arguably beat another P4P'er in Calzaghe)
6) Rafael Marquez
7) Kelly Pavlik
8) Cristian Mijares
9) Antonio Margarito
10) Miguel Cotto

i find it very difficult to get the top 10 in order when taking into consideration skills vs. records and recent results

Good List!!! Probably have Hopkins a little lower, maybe swap him and Pavlik?? But other wise thats pretty much how i got it as well!!

1. Juan Manuel Marquez
2. Manny Pacquiao
3. Kelly Pavlik
4. Antonio Margarito
5. Israel Vasquez
6. Cristan Mijares
7. Paul Williams
8. Arthur Abraham
9. Joe Calzaghe
10. Rafael Marquez
11. Ivan Calderon
12. Miguel Cotto
13. Ricky Hatton
14. Jermain Taylor
15. Joshua Clottey
16. Nate Campbell
17. Juan Manuel Lopez
18. Antonio Tarver
19. Carl Froch
20. Juan Diaz

You must be on smack though!!!