Floyd Mayweather Jr Or Sandy Saddler. Higher On A ATG List?

[Southpaw Great]

Well??????????

[Sugarj]

I'll go with Floyd on this one. Saddler was terrific for the Pep fights but could blow hot and cold and lose fights he should really have won.

Floyd Mayweather's record so far speaks for itself, he has clearly dominated everyone hes faced for well over a decade. The Castillo and De La Hoya fights were close 'ish' and these two at the times he fought them were pound for pound rated but that aside the man is well on his way to legendary status. (A Pacquiou win would be meteoric. With that on his record he could retire as a true legend of the sport).

[Joey Giardello]

Floyd Mayweather

[sonnyboyx2]

Sandy Saddler is the greater, Floyd has avoided everyone who was at the top of their game taking 2yrs off when the welterweight division was at its very best then coming back and beating two guys who was 10yrs past their best, i cannot see Floyd fighting Manny Pacquiao

[Bright-Eyes]

Sandy Saddler is the greater, Floyd has avoided everyone who was at the top of their game taking 2yrs off when the welterweight division was at its very best then coming back and beating two guys who was 10yrs past their best,

I agree with this.