Robert De Niro vs Al Pacino vs Jack Nicholson

[Szef]

Which one of these ATGs is the best and why?

[LADIV]

Which one of these ATGs is the best and why?

al pacino....scarface.. nuff said

[Willy Wanker]

Al Pacino for me. He could play smooth cool guy like De Niro and the aggressive, over the top bat **** crazy guy like Nicholson.

But De Niro had the best movies and the most classics as well as the more diverse resume. Always thought Cape Fear was his most underrated movie and role.

On a side note, I would have loved to see Jack Nicholson play Taxi Driver. He would have brought the more insane, loony side out of Travis Bickle. No one did crazy better than him.

[Randall Cunning]

Jack Nicholson for me. Careers were pretty equal quality wise to the mid 90s. Nicholsons quality control was impeccable to the day he retired. But Jesus, Deniro and Pacino been in some right **** recently, ruining their legacies

[W1LL]

It's really close between De Niro and Pacino. I went with De Niro because I love how he stamps on that fella in Goodfellas.

[Szef]

Jack Nicholson for me. Careers were pretty equal quality wise to the mid 90s. Nicholsons quality control was impeccable to the day he retired. But Jesus, Deniro and Pacino been in some right **** recently, ruining their legacies

I meant who was the best in their prime, but the bolded is definitely true. They've been Roy Jonesing their legacies in recent years, it's sad to watch.

However, they have a chance to redeem themselves in 'The Irishman'. Scorsese, Dr Niro, Pacino, Pesci and Keitel in the same movie? I don't even entertain the thought the movie will suck, it HAS to be good. Well at least I hope it will be.

[Zaroku]

I got a pic with liza... She said

You are fine...young Bob...

[Randall Cunning]

I meant who was the best in their prime, but the bolded is definitely true. They've been Roy Jonesing their legacies in recent years, it's sad to watch.

However, they have a chance to redeem themselves in 'The Irishman'. Scorsese, Dr Niro, Pacino, Pesci and Keitel in the same movie? I don't even entertain the thought the movie will suck, it HAS to be good. Well at least I hope it will be.

When they were all in their prime, 70s and 80s, Deniro just edges it maybe. Nicholson prime went right through til the end of the 00s, still didnt make a bad movie in that decade, hes the Mayweather of the group, probably come out of retirement to star in a James Cameron multi billion dollar blockbuster

[MDPopescu]

Which one of these ATGs is the best and why?

... one can't and doesn't make differences...

De Niro in Taxi Driver... Once Upon A Time in America...
Al Pacino in God Father... Donnie Brasco (?)
Jack Nicholson in One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest... The Postman Always Rings Twice ...

one simply can't...

[AddiX]

Dinero has a Long list of terrible performances and movies that people forget about.