Would Floyd still be undefeated if he had fought..

[dan_cov]

I think he'd beat them all.

A prime Mosley I'd say was the most dangerous but Winky would likely have the most success.

I don't think a younger Cotto does any better than the one that fought Floyd. I thought he brought his A game that night.

[boliodogs]

Winky Wright
Kostya Tszyu
Paul Williams
Antonio Margarito
Prime Mosley
Prime Cotto
Prime Pacquiao
Prime King Khan
Tim Bradley
GGG @154

I think GGG and Wright would beat him at 154. GGG would have knocked him out in my opinion and Wright might edge him out on points but I am not sure on that fight. Maybe a 60/40 fight in Wright's favor.Floyd beats the other 8 in my opinion. I think he could KO a prime Khan in his sleep with ease and Bradley would also be very easy work. I am sure he beats everyone on your list except for GGG and Wright. Floyd is not even a big welterweight and too small for 154 even if he does beat all but the very best at 154. Just my honest opinion because fantasy fights can never be proven one way or the other and everyone is just guessing.

[ELPacman]

Becaus Floyd’s fighting style was strictly defensive with lots of clinching, running, and avoiding combat and using IQ. Being prime or not doesn’t really affect that style, at all.

Where as somebody like Pacquiao whom during his prime utilized his speed, power and high offensive output is completely dictated by him being in his prime.

Brah, that was too much for most to take in. I've been preaching that for years. An aging defensive fighter will typically age better than an aging offensive fighter.

Young Pac's wild offense and very unpredictable movements are what made him beast when he was younger. As he got older and more calculated, it became easier for slower fighters to try and keep up with him. Especially someone who enjoys to pot shot...

[ELPacman]

Oh and regarding this thread, Paul Williams and Margarito would have been fun to watch. Let's keep in mind Jose Luis Castillo beat Mayweather in their first fight.

[powershots]

Fxvk no!!!

[Pac=Duran]

Winky Wright
Kostya Tszyu
Paul Williams
Antonio Margarito
Prime Mosley
Prime Cotto
Prime Pacquiao
Prime King Khan
Tim Bradley
GGG @154

He has the tools to beat them all tbh but I think if he had a career where he fought all those guys, the wear and tear would have been too much and he would have aged earlier and got clipped by GGG or Pacquiao towards the end

[SugarAnt05]

Winky would have been tough, everyone else woulda been UD’d. GGG at 154 woulda been drained, you know a weight clause woulda been added. I will never understand why ppl hype up ****rito . It would have looked like the Baldomir fight. I loved Paul Williams, but come on. He fought short, never truly utilized that height. Khan gives him problems early until he slows down. Floyd actual might be down on the cards until he walks him down for a vicious knockout. That right hand , left hook would been landing flush on that Khan chin. Bambi legs

[Marchegiano]

Yup.

Do y'all knwo what Occam's razor is?

Okay, a man who makes plans, executes them, and has never been wrong. What's the least stretch for answering would variant X be enough to negate that 0?

X / 0 = 0

Simple.

Floyd would come in with the right plan. To say otherwise is more fantasy than to not. Duh.

[LeOoze]

Becaus Floyd’s fighting style was strictly defensive with lots of clinching, running, and avoiding combat and using IQ. Being prime or not doesn’t really affect that style, at all.

Where as somebody like Pacquiao whom during his prime utilized his speed, power and high offensive output is completely dictated by him being in his prime.

You’re an. Did you just start watching boxing in 2012. Floyd’s first half of his career was him knocking everybody out LOL. And somehow even past his prime he still lands more than his opponents.

Have you ever laced up gloves before?

[aboutfkntime]

I think GGG and Wright would beat him at 154. GGG would have knocked him out in my opinion and Wright might edge him out on points but I am not sure on that fight. Maybe a 60/40 fight in Wright's favor.Floyd beats the other 8 in my opinion. I think he could KO a prime Khan in his sleep with ease and Bradley would also be very easy work. I am sure he beats everyone on your list except for GGG and Wright. Floyd is not even a big welterweight and too small for 154 even if he does beat all but the very best at 154. Just my honest opinion because fantasy fights can never be proven one way or the other and everyone is just guessing.

you got no idea about weight, or style

1) he would not be GGG at 154, he would only be GG
2) that boy is slooooow, and predictable... no special effects, and he does not like movement

no chance he could beat Mayweather at 154, prime Mosley would have a better chance... G couldn't hit Floyd with a handful of rice