Props to Inoue for winning but I gotta say I think a 2011 Donaire wins.

[Blue54]

Doniare did well but he def looked old and his legs aren't what they used to be neither was hand and foot speed.

Inoue proved he is top 10 p4p and elite but if this old Doniare gave him this good of a fight you'd Donaire beats him UD prob drops him to.

[Jubei]

Inoue is still a young unexperienced puppy, he just turned 26, give him a couple more years and he will be better.

[D4thincarnation]

A Prime Donaire would give any bantamweight, super-bantamweight in history hell.

[Doctor_Tenma]

It doesn't always work like that, I remember when all Donaire would look for was that counter left hook. He varies his attack now and no I'm not suggesting he's better now, just that he's better in that aspect.

[Gentblue]

A Prime Donaire would give any bantamweight, super-bantamweight in history hell.

Are you Sure about that.....

[boliodogs]

I have yet to see the fight but if he can come this close to winning at his age he might well have won in his prime. Prime Donaire in his proper weight class was a hell of a fighter. His bad losses came from fighting too far above his best fighting weight.

[Blue54]

It doesn't always work like that, I remember when all Donaire would look for was that counter left hook. He varies his attack now and no I'm not suggesting he's better now, just that he's better in that aspect.

That's true he relied to much on left hook but he was more dangerous then faster more quicker on the attack plus better reflexes.

[RuleOfTheSpear]

Prime Donaire was undefeated at bantamweight and for good reason.

[tjones1989]

If old man Donaire could wobble, bloody, and break the orbital bone of the supposed "monster" in Inoue; prime Donaire would have decapitated that boi inoue. This is absolute truth.

[Zaryu]

Donaire's reflexes were sick during his prime. I think Donaire from 2011 could have beaten the current Inoue, but it still would've been a great fight and one that Inoue could also win.