Who wins: the Pacquiao that beat Margarito vs the Canelo that lost to Mayweather?

[South Champion]

Pacquiao beat Margarito at Light Middleweight at a catchweight. Canelo lost to Mayweather at Light Middleweight at a catchweight.

Pacquiao started at Minimumweight, while Canelo just won a title at Light Heavyweight.

But if the Light Middleweight version of Pacquiao fought the version of Canelo that fought Mayweather, who would win?

[BM dnobagaV]

Given those versions of the fighters we saw that night?
Canelo gives him a tough fight in a few spots but he gets absolutely slaughtered in the process. Wouldn't be remotely competitive in my mind.

2010 Pacquiao versus 2018 Canelo would be the real fight to see.

[muslimer12]

Pacquiao destroys him. But Canelo at his best is above 160

[ShaneMosleySr]

Pacquiao...

[PRINCEKOOL]

The fight would be similar to Pacquiao vs Cotto, Canelo Alvarez is just TOO once paced plus? I don't think he has many gears.

Pacquiao would definitely win the fight, the corner would most likely stop the fight 'Due to Canelo Alvarez being exhausted and taking too much punishment'.

[IronDanHamza]

Pacquaio probably wins but Canelo's counterpunnching would definitely trouble him.

[DumpkinsPlus5]

Canelo by knockout

[FredRekk]

****** thread. Pac would TKO that Green Nelo in 8 rounds.

During that time, every opponent Mayweather beat, PAC SLAUGHTERED.

Margarito was a much harder hitting taller opponent then Green Nelo. PAC SLAUGHTERS GREEN NELO.

[mxtali]

****** thread. Pac would TKO that Green Nelo in 8 rounds.

During that time, every opponent Mayweather beat, PAC SLAUGHTERED.

Margarito was a much harder hitting taller opponent then Green Nelo. PAC SLAUGHTERS GREEN NELO.

Margarito hit harder than that Canelo based on what?

[Jsmooth9876]

The Pac going into the Margarito fight wins. The one that came out wasn't the same. Margarito wasn't in his prime but he put a hurting on little Pac in that fight