Which boxer gave Floyd Mayweather Jr his toughest fight?

[ShoulderRoll]

Who would you say troubled Floyd the most in the ring?

Jose Luis Castillo?

Marcos Maidana?

Emmanuel Augustus?

Or someone else?

[GhostofDempsey]

The three who beat him...Castillo, DLH and Maidana.

[ShoulderRoll]

The three who beat him...Castillo, DLH and Maidana.

I disagree that ODLH and Maidana beat him.

I can see an argument for Castillo, though.

[GhostofDempsey]

I disagree that ODLH and Maidana beat him.

I can see an argument for Castillo, though.

I say that without any bias, seriously. I had ODH 115-113. The fight was a split decision and close, so an argument could be made either way.

I thought Maidana was the aggressor, out-worked him, pressured him, took him out of his comfort zone, and was much busier of the two. Talking the first fight of course.

[chrisJS]

I say that without any bias, seriously. I had ODH 115-113. The fight was a split decision and close, so an argument could be made either way.

I thought Maidana was the aggressor, out-worked him, pressured him, took him out of his comfort zone, and was much busier of the two. Talking the first fight of course.

I agree. Even Floyd SR said he thought De La Hoya won.

[DEVOURER]

juan luis castillo. he outright beat floyd.

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

De La Hoya IMO, that was an extremely close fight that could’ve easily went either way

[djtmal]

i got a better question which one of floyd's cherrypicks went against the script better...

[WORSHIP]

Castillo definitely, nobody else came close

[FrankieClutch]

I had it:

Castillo 7-5
Maidana 6-6
and Floyd over Oscar 7-5