Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Where is the history of byrd being some terrible judge?

Collapse
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
    #1

    Where is the history of byrd being some terrible judge?

    Yes this card was wide thats understood.. but people are acting like shes always been a bad judge for years or something.. arum complained and didnt want her to do the loma fight for some reason but wheres her history of being crap?
    #2
    I posted it in another thread. There is a mention to her horrible scoring in that Arum article. In MMA forums she's been considered a curse to the sport for years too. Since Boxing is more spread out then the UFC is I think a lot of boxing fans aren't up on bad judges as much as UFC fans tend to be with judges who work both sides of the fence.

    Comment

      #3
      Originally posted by GriffTannen View Post
      Yes this card was wide thats understood.. but people are acting like shes always been a bad judge for years or something.. arum complained and didnt want her to do the loma fight for some reason but wheres her history of being crap?
      She scored it 3-0 for a UFC fighter when in reality the other fighter won every round. Dana White was going off on her in the past.

      Comment

        #4
        Originally posted by Vegemil View Post
        She scored it 3-0 for a UFC fighter when in reality the other fighter won every round. Dana White was going off on her in the past.
        Ok... So thats 3 bad rounds

        Comment

          #5
          Originally posted by Vegemil View Post
          She scored it 3-0 for a UFC fighter when in reality the other fighter won every round. Dana White was going off on her in the past.
          idk about her ufc scoring im just talking boxing

          Comment

            #6
            Originally posted by GGG Gloveking View Post
            Ok... So thats 3 bad rounds
            It was a 3 round fight I believe. Lemme try to find the link.

            Comment

              #7
              i dont know but theres plenty of history of you being a terrible poster

              Comment

                #8
                Originally posted by DramaShow View Post
                i dont know but theres plenty of history of you being a terrible poster
                sure, just let me know when ohara davies is the next british superstar

                Comment

                  #9
                  Thing is, it only takes one bad night in boxing to do irreparable damage, either as a judge or a ref. You can be a great ref, but have one bad night like Richard Steele, Pat Russell or Weeks and be labeled an incompetent moron.

                  Byrd screwed up the scoring for Hopkins/Calzaghe, fortunately it didn't cost Calzaghe the fight. Her scorecard on Saturday was as bad as CJ Ross scoring of Manny/Bradley and Floyd/Canelo. Incompetent and/or corrupt judges can have a serious impact on a fighter's career and potential earnings.

                  Burt Clements didn't know how to score three knockdowns in a round, so he cost Manny a win versus Marquez in their first fight because he is incompetent. It should have been overturned. Look at Melvina Lathan, another incompetent mess. Dave Moretti usually turns in some outrageous scorecards as well. Duane Ford another senile old fart.

                  I think judges should have to score the fight while watching it on a big screen television. You have a much better vantage point with up close camera angles than you do sitting at ringside. Especially when the fight is taking place on the other side of the ring and the ref is in your field of view.
                  Last edited by GhostofDempsey; 09-19-2017, 02:27 PM.

                  Comment

                    #10
                    Despite the history, anybody can get flipped in an instant.

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    X
                    TOP