Who WON: Mauricio Herrera OR Danny Garcia? (POLL)

[STREET CLEANER]

I watched that fight again and recomfirmed the draw that I saw the first time around.

[IronDanHamza]

Scored it for Garcia.

Extremely close fight. Barely any dominant rounds in the whole fight.

[Tom Cruise]

Scored it for Garcia.

Extremely close fight. Barely any dominant rounds in the whole fight.

Really Dan?

You got a scorecard? Not trying to flame its just you must have seen the fight differently to mostly everyone else

[IronDanHamza]

Really Dan?

You got a scorecard? Not trying to flame its just you must have seen the fight differently to mostly everyone else

Yeah. I mean it's a very hard fight to score, almost every round was a case of neither man doing very impressive or effective work.

This is how I scored it.

Round 1 - Garcia - Close. Feel out for both
Round 2 - Herrera - Close
Round 3 - Garcia - Very close
Round 4 - Garcia - Very close. Garcia had a better first half, Herrera the better of the second half.
Round 5 - Herrera - Close..Again. Herrera doing more and landing more but still not really dominant

Every round so far, neither have clearly won any of the rounds

Round 6 - Garcia. Nothing effective from either. Gave it Garcia because his punches were hard and solid (Albeit seldom) whereas Herrera landed some solid jabs but he wasn't as effective as he was in earlier rounds with it.

Round 7 - Garcia. Almost a carbon copy of Round 6. A lot of these rounds could easily go for Herrera.

So out of the first 7 Rounds I struggle to see a clear round for either man. Perhaps the 5th for Herrera.

Round 8 - Herrera. Probably the clearest Round thus far. Still not a "Dominant" round really

Round 9 - Herrera, clear round.

Round 10 - Garcia. Best round of the fight. Both doing good work. Garcia IMO having the slight better work but still an either way round

Round 11 - Garcia - clear

Round 12 - Herrera - clear.

So final score 115-113 for Garcia.

Easily could have been a draw and could obviously very easily have been a Herrera win with the amount of extremely close rounds.

I've been away for the last week so I've literally just watched the fight about an hour ago.

I was genuinely expecting Herrera to dominate about 8 or 9 rounds. Considering the "robbery claims".

I want to know 7 rounds than Herrera clearly won because I cannot see it.

[HeroBando]

Yeah. I mean it's a very hard fight to score, almost every round was a case of neither man doing very impressive or effective work.

This is how I scored it.

Round 1 - Garcia - Close. Feel out for both
Round 2 - Herrera - Close
Round 3 - Garcia - Very close
Round 4 - Garcia - Very close. Garcia had a better first half, Herrera the better of the second half.
Round 5 - Herrera - Close..Again. Herrera doing more and landing more but still not really dominant

Every round so far, neither have clearly won any of the rounds

Round 6 - Garcia. Nothing effective from either. Gave it Garcia because his punches were hard and solid (Albeit seldom) whereas Herrera landed some solid jabs but he wasn't as effective as he was in earlier rounds with it.

Round 7 - Garcia. Almost a carbon copy of Round 6. A lot of these rounds could easily go for Herrera.

So out of the first 7 Rounds I struggle to see a clear round for either man. Perhaps the 5th for Herrera.

Round 8 - Herrera. Probably the clearest Round thus far. Still not a "Dominant" round really

Round 9 - Herrera, clear round.

Round 10 - Garcia. Best round of the fight. Both doing good work. Garcia IMO having the slight better work but still an either way round

Round 11 - Garcia - clear

Round 12 - Herrera - clear.

So final score 115-113 for Garcia.

Easily could have been a draw and could obviously very easily have been a Herrera win with the amount of extremely close rounds.

I've been away for the last week so I've literally just watched the fight about an hour ago.

I was genuinely expecting Herrera to dominate about 8 or 9 rounds. Considering the "robbery claims".

I want to know 7 rounds than Herrera clearly won because I cannot see it.

Garcia got a ton of benefit of the doubt to be up 5-2 on your cards

[Ringlife]

I had Garcia winning this fight.

[IronDanHamza]

Garcia got a ton of benefit of the doubt to be up 5-2 on your cards

Like I said it could easily have been the exact same score but the other way around.

I feel scoring the rounds for either man were mostly a case of "Benefit of the doubt"

Neither were impressive or doing dominant enough work to take most of the rounds.

[Da Machine]

When 83% score it for one guy, it usually means only one thing. No it doesn't mean that the 17% are special and saw something we didn't. It means that guy who got 83% of the votes won the fight.

I mean this **** is settled at this point. Why do you think Garcia wants to fight an even bigger chump in his next fight? Why do you think his dad had a look of disgust on his face after the fight?

[IronDanHamza]

When 83% score it for one guy, it usually means only one thing. No it doesn't mean that the 17% are special and saw something we didn't. It means that guy who got 83% of the votes won the fight.

I mean this **** is settled at this point. Why do you think Garcia wants to fight an even bigger chump in his next fight? Why do you think his dad had a look of disgust on his face after the fight?

And what were the actual scorecards of the 83%? Were they blow outs?

According to the sources I've found. The scorecards either way were no wider than 116-112.

[UTEP]

And what were the actual scorecards of the 83%? Were they blow outs?

According to the sources I've found. The scorecards either way were no wider than 116-112.

8-4 Garcia


Let me guess, you also had Bradley/Pac 8-4, just like Timmy?