Matthysse vs Garcia - Would Matthysse have won with both eyes?

[FerFAL]

I guess Garcia's punches didn't have nothing to do with his victory. If Lucas eye wouldn't had gotten swollen then it would be if Garcia won because of the low blows, holding, bad ref, etc.....

It is what it is. If Danny could have won without the constant clinching and dozen punches to the balls he would have done so, but that's what he needed to do to have a chance of winning. Knowing GBP would take care of any chance of him getting DQ or too many points deducted he obviously went for it.
Same thing with Maidana. El Chino was boxing and Broner was fighting an MMA fight, throwing as much elbows as actual punches at some point, then there's the humping and punching after the bell, all that an not a point deducted? Come on. Even then he couldnt win, but luck had a lot to do with. Luck and dominating Broner to such an extent, but any of those elbows Broner threw could have opened up a cut in Maidana, costing him the fight, or the punch he threw after the bell rang could have KO him or wound him enough so that Broner got an unfair victory in the 12th.
Boxing shouldnt be this way and that's that, rules should be followed like in any other sport. It really isnt that much to ask. You get a warning, then you lose a point, then you go *** yourself and get DQ until you can man up and fight fairly.

[Tom Cruise]

Matthysse got his ass whooped. That wouldn't have changed. Closed eye or not.

Btw, I love the Matthysse nuthuggers try to use that as an excuse.

All I know is that Lucas Matthyse got his ass wupped.. So it doesn't matter because we all seen him get his ass lit up.

'Ass whoopins' generally arent close (but clear) decisions where the winner had to fight hard right up until the final bell.

If this was an 'ass whooping' then god knows what you guys would think of Mayweather vs Gatti or something like that

[A-Wolf]

lmao all the people coming out in droves to go the other way again because they picked this fight dead wrong.

[UTEP]

Matthysse got his ass whooped. That wouldn't have changed. Closed eye or not.

Btw, I love the Matthysse nuthuggers try to use that as an excuse.

'Ass whoopins' generally arent close (but clear) decisions where the winner had to fight hard right up until the final bell.

If this was an 'ass whooping' then god knows what you guys would think of Mayweather vs Gatti or something like that

He's a Floyd fan what did you expect? Losing by 1 round is considered an "ass whooping" to them.

[El Angel]

He was on my card before he got hurt. I think with two healthy eyes, he wins a UD.

[HanzGruber]

Lol at the lucastards clinging on to hope still. This is ***in ******ed you can say this about literally anything. "Bradley woulda beat PAC if he didnt hurt his ankles" "PAC woulda best Marquez if he didnt get lazy" just stop already his eye closed cause Danny was punching that face first brawler

[MDPopescu]

lmao all the people coming out in droves to go the other way again because they picked this fight dead wrong.

... A high percentage of people picked the fight as Lucas by KO...
... The scorecards were 114-112, 115-111, 114-112 (with Lucas dropped in the 11th and with Danny losing a point in the 12th)... Rather a "hard fought victory" than a "whooping"...

[SlyRaccoon]

'Ass whoopins' generally arent close (but clear) decisions where the winner had to fight hard right up until the final bell.

If this was an 'ass whooping' then god knows what you guys would think of Mayweather vs Gatti or something like that

It wasn't close. Matthyse got his ASS WHUPPED!! You can tell Garcia is guilty of crime when you look at his victim in the face, and then he see his ass curlt up on the mat.

[Tom Cruise]

It wasn't close. Matthyse got his ASS WHUPPED!! You can tell Garcia is guilty of crime when you look at his victim in the face, and then he see his ass curlt up on the mat.

Because the condition of someones face is how they score fights

[Tom Cruise]

"And we're coming into the 12th and final round, Matthysse is losing clear by 1 eye swelling to 0. He's gonna need to put at least a couple a' cuts on Danny to have any chance on the cards... a nose bleed is not enough now"