What is Miguel Cotto's "Best/Career Defining" Win?

[joesaiditstrue]

Or does he have one (in your opinion)?

[DAN916]

I dont know about career defining but Torres VS Cotto is one of my favorites.

[Public_Enemy]

I would say Shane Mosley. That was big for Cotto. The Margarito win is career defining as well. Even though Margarito was diminished, Cotto needed that win. He needed to exercise those demons.

[Slyboots]

I would say either Paulie or Shane. Sure Shane wasn't at his absolute prime, but he wasn't too far from it and was still a beast. I mean he sodomized Margarito after the Cotto fight, that's saying quite a bit.

[4Corners]

A past prime still good Mosley was his best win.

Cotto is a very good fighter, who was vastly and still is overrated by many though.

Jose Luis Castillo has a better resume of wins in my opinion, and even Diego Corrales is right up there with him. Seriously, just look at the wins for those three guys.

[spytactics]

Shane, marg, and when he beat his uncle trainer

[Prime 407]

Mosely and he beat down Judah pretty good too.

[Snake...]

A past prime still good Mosley was his best win.

Cotto is a very good fighter, who was vastly and still is overrated by many though.

Jose Luis Castillo has a better resume of wins in my opinion, and even Diego Corrales is right up there with him. Seriously, just look at the wins for those three guys.

I agree with this

[Earl-Hickey]

Probably judah in terms of how impressively he beat him and not just the name

[cantor5150]

he has Mosley, Judah, Margarito, Mayorga & Paulie has top names but he also beat many undefeated guys with KO power like Maussa (17-0, 16ko) Pinto (21-0, 19ko) Bailey (28-4, 27ko) Torres (28-0, 25ko) Quintana (23-0, 18ko) and few others like Clottey & Gomez....

keep in mind these rec are from when he fought them, not up to date rec.