Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Comments Thread For: Roach Upset: Ruslan Should've Had Three 10-8 Rounds

Collapse
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    #91
    Originally posted by ThatDude44 View Post
    Roach seems to be on a huge win streak, lol.
    Yeah man, he caught two on Saturday night. I feel kind of bad for the guy but he had no advice for Ruslan at all in there while Diaz had all the right advice for Tim, he just didn't listen.

    Comment


      #92
      Originally posted by mathed View Post
      Well, to be fair, you might as well score round 3 a 10-8 for Bradley as Ruslan threw like 7 punches and got dominated for the entire 3 minutes. Would that be fair as well?
      Every non KD 10-8 round i can think of has a guy hurt and pummeled on. It's usually a, "can he make it out" kinda deal

      Comment


        #93
        A fighter being out on their feet doesn't equal a 10-8 round. Prov had Bradley hurt but it was:

        1) Usually towards the end of a round.

        2) Bradley was competitive for a significant period of the first two rounds.

        It's akin to saying the second round in Mosley v Mayweather should have been scored 10-8.

        Comment


          #94
          Originally posted by FeFist View Post
          A fighter being out on their feet doesn't equal a 10-8 round. Prov had Bradley hurt but it was:

          1) Usually towards the end of a round.

          2) Bradley was competitive for a significant period of the first two rounds.

          It's akin to saying the second round in Mosley v Mayweather should have been scored 10-8.
          that was round 1 and 6. he was out for long stretches of round 2, and staggered several times. you had to wonder, how did he even survive the round

          Comment


            #95
            Here's the press scores for the fight:

            Scott Christ (BadleftHook) : 114-113 Bradley

            Victor Salazar (ThaBoxingVoice) : 114-113 Bradley

            Nes (TheBoxingVoice) :115-112 Bradley

            Mike Coppinger (USA Today) : 113-113 Draw

            Phil D Jay (***************) : 113-113 Draw

            Gabriel Montoya (Maxboxing) : 113-113 Draw

            Steve Kim (Maxboxing) : 113-113 Draw

            ESPN.COM : 113-113 Draw

            Boxing Socialist : 114-113 Bradley

            Matt Christie (BoxingNews) : 115-114 Bradley

            Brian Campbell (ESPN) : 113-113 Draw

            Harold Lederman (HBO) : 115-112 Bradley

            Dan Rafael (ESPN) : 114-112 Bradley

            Steve Zemach (QueensburyRules) : 113-112 Provodnikov

            Eric Raskin (Boxingmonthly) : 113-112 Bradley

            Al Bernstein (Showtime) : 114-113 Bradley

            Cliff Roid (Boxingscene) : 115-112 Bradley

            Mark Ortega (Ring TV) : 115-112 Provodnikov

            ThaBoxingvoice : 115-112 Bradley

            Boxingopinions : 115-113 Bradley

            Ryan Bivins (***********) : 114-112 Bradley

            Kugan Cassius (IFILM London) : 114-112 Bradley

            *********.com : 114-113 Bradley

            Tim Starks (TheQueensburyRules) : 114-113 Bradley

            Michael Woods (The SweetScience) : 113-112 Provodnikov

            Ernest Gabion (TheBoxingLab) : 114-113 Provodnikov

            Ramon Aranda (3MoreRounds) : 114-113 Provodnikov

            Boxing.com : 113-112 Bradley

            Billy Ferguson (FightHype) : 114-113 Bradley

            Darren Velasco (FightDomain) : 114-113 Bradley

            Corey Quincy (***********) : 114-113 Bradley

            Ryan Burton (The BoxingLab) : 114-113 Bradley

            Corey Erdman (******) : 113-112 Bradley

            Nigel Collins (ESPN) : 114-112 Provodnikov

            Associated Press : 114-113 Bradley

            Tim Kudgis (ATG Radio) : 115-112 Bradley

            FightGhost : 114-114 Draw

            Tris Dixon (BoxingNews) : 114-112 Bradley

            Matthew Mojica (TheFightSource) : 113-113 Draw

            Alex Morris (************) : 114-113 Provodnikov

            BoxingBetPL : 114-113 Bradley

            Steve Lillis (Boxnation) : 114-114 Draw

            Steve Bunce (Boxnation) : 114-113 Bradley`

            Kieran Mulvaney (ESPN) : 114-112 Bradley

            Andy Paterson (************) : 114-113 Bradley

            Paul Daley (Topsclassboxing) : 114-113 Bradley

            Tom Gray (Ring ****zine) : 115-112 Bradley

            The Title Fight : 114-113 Bradley

            Lee John Wyle (TheSweetScience) : 115-112 Bradley

            Proboxing-fans Jake : 115-112 Bradley

            Kevin Mitchell (Observer) : 113-113 Draw

            Matty D (************) : 114-113 Bradley

            Comment


              #96
              Originally posted by FeFist View Post
              A fighter being out on their feet doesn't equal a 10-8 round. Prov had Bradley hurt but it was:

              1) Usually towards the end of a round.

              2) Bradley was competitive for a significant period of the first two rounds.

              It's akin to saying the second round in Mosley v Mayweather should have been scored 10-8.
              The *** it dont!!!!

              Comment


                #97
                Russlan was robbed of the first KD in the fight. There was clearly enough evidence to determine that Bradley was hurt before he was leaned on.

                That said, I'd still give Bradley the fight (by 1 point even with the RD 1 KD). He deserved that win.

                Hell of a fight.

                Comment


                  #98
                  Originally posted by HeroBando View Post
                  Every non KD 10-8 round i can think of has a guy hurt and pummeled on. It's usually a, "can he make it out" kinda deal
                  I agree but I'm just saying where do you draw the line? I could see a 10-8 in the 12th (obviously) and 2nd for Provid best case but the 1st round involved an elbow on the back and a shove. I am a huge Bradley fan but I can at least admit that he took Provid lightly to a degree and fought the wrong fight.

                  It's just that when you start talking the 10-8 round stuff with no KD, you get to the point where guys are screaming for a 10-8 because one man landed a few less punches than the other guy. Bradley is the champ and has a history of being able to weather the storm, maybe that played a part but I personally only give 10-10 rounds and no 10-8 unless there is a KD.

                  Comment


                    #99
                    Originally posted by PBP View Post
                    Here's the press scores for the fight:

                    Scott Christ (BadleftHook) : 114-113 Bradley

                    Victor Salazar (ThaBoxingVoice) : 114-113 Bradley

                    Nes (TheBoxingVoice) :115-112 Bradley

                    Mike Coppinger (USA Today) : 113-113 Draw

                    Phil D Jay (***************) : 113-113 Draw

                    Gabriel Montoya (Maxboxing) : 113-113 Draw

                    Steve Kim (Maxboxing) : 113-113 Draw

                    ESPN.COM : 113-113 Draw

                    Boxing Socialist : 114-113 Bradley

                    Matt Christie (BoxingNews) : 115-114 Bradley

                    Brian Campbell (ESPN) : 113-113 Draw

                    Harold Lederman (HBO) : 115-112 Bradley

                    Dan Rafael (ESPN) : 114-112 Bradley

                    Steve Zemach (QueensburyRules) : 113-112 Provodnikov

                    Eric Raskin (Boxingmonthly) : 113-112 Bradley

                    Al Bernstein (Showtime) : 114-113 Bradley

                    Cliff Roid (Boxingscene) : 115-112 Bradley

                    Mark Ortega (Ring TV) : 115-112 Provodnikov

                    ThaBoxingvoice : 115-112 Bradley

                    Boxingopinions : 115-113 Bradley

                    Ryan Bivins (***********) : 114-112 Bradley

                    Kugan Cassius (IFILM London) : 114-112 Bradley

                    *********.com : 114-113 Bradley

                    Tim Starks (TheQueensburyRules) : 114-113 Bradley

                    Michael Woods (The SweetScience) : 113-112 Provodnikov

                    Ernest Gabion (TheBoxingLab) : 114-113 Provodnikov

                    Ramon Aranda (3MoreRounds) : 114-113 Provodnikov

                    Boxing.com : 113-112 Bradley

                    Billy Ferguson (FightHype) : 114-113 Bradley

                    Darren Velasco (FightDomain) : 114-113 Bradley

                    Corey Quincy (***********) : 114-113 Bradley

                    Ryan Burton (The BoxingLab) : 114-113 Bradley

                    Corey Erdman (******) : 113-112 Bradley

                    Nigel Collins (ESPN) : 114-112 Provodnikov

                    Associated Press : 114-113 Bradley

                    Tim Kudgis (ATG Radio) : 115-112 Bradley

                    FightGhost : 114-114 Draw

                    Tris Dixon (BoxingNews) : 114-112 Bradley

                    Matthew Mojica (TheFightSource) : 113-113 Draw

                    Alex Morris (************) : 114-113 Provodnikov

                    BoxingBetPL : 114-113 Bradley

                    Steve Lillis (Boxnation) : 114-114 Draw

                    Steve Bunce (Boxnation) : 114-113 Bradley`

                    Kieran Mulvaney (ESPN) : 114-112 Bradley

                    Andy Paterson (************) : 114-113 Bradley

                    Paul Daley (Topsclassboxing) : 114-113 Bradley

                    Tom Gray (Ring ****zine) : 115-112 Bradley

                    The Title Fight : 114-113 Bradley

                    Lee John Wyle (TheSweetScience) : 115-112 Bradley

                    Proboxing-fans Jake : 115-112 Bradley

                    Kevin Mitchell (Observer) : 113-113 Draw

                    Matty D (************) : 114-113 Bradley

                    Not a bad mix and pretty even scoring except for Ortega, my gosh what fight was he watching? He just looks for head snaps apparently, what about the 120+ extra punches Bradley landed?

                    Ah, 3 10-8 rounds.........I guess

                    Comment


                      Originally posted by mathed View Post
                      Not a bad mix and pretty even scoring except for Ortega, my gosh what fight was he watching? He just looks for head snaps apparently, what about the 120+ extra punches Bradley landed?

                      Ah, 3 10-8 rounds.........I guess
                      Yeah that's the one clear outlier. The rest look good. 114-113, 115-112 Bradley seem to be the majority. The close round in the fight was 11 that could have gone either way.

                      All these biased trolls and hating ass *****es can go you know where talking about this fight was a "robbery" or a "gift" though. The scorecards say otherwise.

                      One reason why I love that site.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      X
                      TOP