Manny Pacquiao is definitely a top 5 ATG alongside Langford/Greb/Robinson/Ali.

[hugh grant]

Well Pac is pretty special. He was made for JMM, yet JMM couldnt beat him in 3 attempts.
JMM was supposed to be Pacs kryptonite, yet Pac beats him 3 times.

When people are supposedly made for Pac, they end up being either viciously koed by Pac or Pac wins by 12 rounds, but having said that, they probably wernt made for Pac, its just a excuse people use to justify how Pac was able to make very good fighters look ordinary.

Pac deserves top 10 for a incredible tough scedule of regular fighting for 8 years non stop and steamrolling through everyone in his path, and is a good role model for fighters to try go out and achieve and not rest on your laurels and try protect your zeros.

[djeffectz]

1. Ali
11. Pac
13. Jones
22. Mayweather

I dont think Pac is top 5, not even top 10.

[Check_hooks]

I have Pac top 5 but his legacy is still being written

People need to stop overrating old fighters, this happens alot with baseball as well

Some people think Babe Ruth was the greatest baseball player of all time

[BartBears]

No one else really comes close in terms of accomplishments, resume, contributions to the sport.

I rank Manny ahead of Armstrong/Leonard for many factors. Longevity, ability to fight, resume.

No doubt my friend......Pac is top 5 ATG....haters deal with it

[BartBears]

I think you have it right.

But thinking about it seriously for a moment, if it's worth it, Pacquiao might be top 50, possibly top 40.

Just thinking of welterweights, you could break one of Robinson's arms and he'd still lick Pacquiao. And La Motta would bully the **** out of Pacquiao. Armstrong the same. Leonard would have boxed the living daylights out of Pacquiao, and Hearns might have killed him, and Duran... lol... Pacquiao would barely be able to land on Duran. José Napoles? lmao! That would have been an embarrassing schooling for Pacquiao after possibly busying himself a couple of early rounds.

IMO Pacquiao was awesome against Cotto, and very good against Margarito, but in case this thread is legit, Pac might, might just be a top-10 welterweight. There's no way he's a top-5 p4p.

All woulda coulda.........look at the resume you *****

[WARQUEZ]

all woulda coulda.........look at the resume you *****

look at the resume! He's the greatest! You tell him Bart.