Is Joe Calzaghe an ATG?

[NoLove]

I voted no because he didn't prove it. He might be talent wise but he never stepped up and proved it.

[Money_May]

Yes ..........

[hugh grant]

Yes anyone that hard to beat deserves to be ATG. Some tried to say Lacy would beat him, underating JC, so JC should be given compensation and benefit of the doubt, if there is any doubts about him being an ATG, and im not sure that there is genuine doubt, rather people trying to deny him, just like they did with him against Lacy!

Well it wont be tolerated. He was so hard to beat that people were sure if he went to america to challenge americas best, surely JC would lose, (the other unbeaten so called ATG floyd wont do it) and the ever reliable BH was the man to do it, cos BH dont lose to white men does he? But BH did.

JC is an ATG for proving the doubters wrong. And if you say he isnt an ATG, you would be wrong again. So save yourself the time and effort of being wrong again.
Thanks for listening.

[STREET CLEANER]

Carl Froch has already done more than Joe to this point

[GUEVARA]

Floyds resume is 10 times better. + he is a 5 weight champ.

Floyd has a resume?

10 x better too?

he is a 5 weight champ?

[Walt Liquor]

he doesnt have the resume to be an atg.

hall of fame, yes. no way atg, no fawkin way

[SpeedKillz]

its tough for me to say. i love calz, but i cant say whether he is an ATG or not, I voted no, but I can be swayed...

[IronDanHamza]

Absolutely not.

Not even close.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

No............................

[yoz]

I'm undecided on Calzaghe.

Don't get me wrong, he was a great boxer; it's just his resume.

LOL @ the people who still think Hopkins was robbed.