who's greater joe calzaghe or winky wright

[J-Smooth]

who will be remembered as the greater fighter

[project xxx1]

joe calzaghe all day long.......

[DeadLikeMe]

Calzaghe will be remembered more, but prime Winky was better and really was something to see.

[Dudley]

JOE for sure! i love wink but the work rate alone would be a bit much for wink. plus wink had a good defense but didn't have actual stopping power. Joe in a very close fight for sure!

[IronDanHamza]

I think it's argubale, despite thinking Winky isn't at all a lock for the HOF.

I really don't rate Calzaghe highly at all on any list other than the ATG SMW and British fighters list.

[ИATAS]

Winky fought guys in their primes and took a lot of challenges. He also fought far better opposition.

[wazaa.]

LOL !!

Winky and it's not even close.

[sammiza567]

winky by far. remind me those who picked calzaghe, at what point in time was he ranked in the top 3 on the p4p list. retiring with an undefeated record and claim to be great but you never cracked 10 ten on most p4p lists b/c he didnt fight anyone. winky was concensus #3 p4p for a while. nobody wanted to fight him. joe had the more glorious career b/c of promotion but winky is by far the greater fighter by far. lmfao to the guy talking about winky vs. calzaghe. winkys was a small middleweight and legit 154 most of his career.

[Dudley]

Ok I'm flopping. I was thinking late winky... the winky that showed up against Vargas was a beast! and he did take on challenges. i just the weight difference could be a slight issue.

[IronDanHamza]

winky by far. remind me those who picked calzaghe, at what point in time was he ranked in the top 3 on the p4p list. retiring with an undefeated record and claim to be great but you never cracked 10 ten on most p4p lists b/c he didnt fight anyone. winky was concensus #3 p4p for a while. nobody wanted to fight him. joe had the more glorious career b/c of promotion but winky is by far the greater fighter by far. lmfao to the guy talking about winky vs. calzaghe. winkys was a small middleweight and legit 154 most of his career.

In fairness, Calzaghe was considered a Top P4P fighter on most list's for the last part of his career.

Not that that really means anything.