Who's bigger Sergio Martinez,Oscar delaHoya or Margarito

[jrosales13]

So according to your logic, PAC should take the fight at 140 because that's his advantage....but you want the fight at 154 so PAC is at a disadvantage LOL.

Pac should take what fight? What are you talking about now?

[ModernTalking]

Of course Pac can, now would he be healthy is a different story, you dumb fuck.

LOL somebody getting mad here. At 140 PAC will be more healthier than Martinez at 154.

[jrosales13]

LOL somebody getting mad here. At 140 PAC will be more healthier than Martinez at 154.

Maybe, what's your point?

[ModernTalking]

Pac should take what fight? What are you talking about now?

It doesn't matter who's Pac is fighting, you talking about people fighting at a disadvantage. You want PAC to fight Martinez and you say that at 150 Martinez will be at a disadvantage. You want a Martinez vs PAC fight at 154 so Martinez doesn't have a disadvantage. So where does that leave PAC than LOL. You think PAC will have a advantage at 154 LOL.

[jrosales13]

It doesn't matter who's Pac is fighting, you talking about people fighting at a disadvantage. You want PAC to fight Martinez and you say that at 150 Martinez will be at a disadvantage. You want a Martinez vs PAC fight at 154 so Martinez doesn't have a disadvantage. So where does that leave PAC than LOL. You think PAC will have a advantage at 154 LOL.

Where did I say that?

The question is who's the bigger out of 3 guys and I answered it.

Not once did I mention who Pac should fight in this thread.

[Bushbaby]

All 3 are damn near the same size.The thing with weight is age.Martinez fought at 147 at 1 time,just like the other 2.Martinez is also the oldest of the 3.Oscar couldn't make 147,we all saw how that ended up.Margarito needed slim fast or some **** to make 150.

[Slick_Rick]

There's a massive contradiction here, the same people who dont want Martinez to come down to 150 are the same people who want Pac to go down to 135 for Marquez

Though i would like Pac to fight Marquez at 135 and Martinez at 154 or 155 for MW, but then you have got to put things into perspective

And Martinez is the biggest, you just need look at his body composition. The guy has a thicker core then both. But then again, what does that matter, Pac has said 150 or below.

[KESSLER]

1. Sergio Martinez
2. Oscar De La Hoya
3. Antonio Margarito

I'm really not sure who's bigger between Margarito and Oscar. Martinez is biggest of the three though, no doubt about it.

[edgarg]

I can hardly believe that I've read through 8 pages waiting to find some realistic postulation as to WHY X was bigger than Y, and I didn't find it, except slightly in the last post before mine, which touched on that Martinez was "thicker"........Several others also said that Martinez was the biggest, but gave no logical reasons. Not logical to me anyway.

These are the facts as I have been able to find them.

Martinez is the bigger, Margarito is next, and Oscar is the smallest.

My reasoning; Laszlo Papp began as an amateur welter and fought as a pro middle. He was 5'5" tall. but he was stocky and broad shouldered and full of muscle.

There are thousands of other examples. how do you think that Paul Williams can fight as a middleweight and as a welterweight when he is ..what..about 6'1" or 6' 2",

The big secret is the skeleton, the frame, the weight and density of the bones, the shape or broadness of the skeleton which governs just how much solid muscle it can carry.

Oscar began as a 130lb'er, as low as 128. His bones are lighter and of smaller circumference. There's no contest here.

Martinez began as a welterweight, obviously has heavier bones and is broader than Oscar, can carry more muscle, and could NEVER in anyone's wildest dreams to be imagined as ever being 130 like Oscar.

Margarito, began as a lightweight, well inside the limit, but he was only still aged 15, and still growing., so we can say that he was a welterweight, which he soon became as he grew.

There is only about a half-an-inch difference in height between each from Margarito down to Martinez, and height anyway MAKES NO DIFFERENCE.

Martinez is the BIGGEST of the three, Margarito is next and Oscar is the smallest.

Oh boy!

[» HE3R0 «]

I can hardly believe that I've read through 8 pages waiting to find some realistic postulation as to WHY X was bigger than Y, and I didn't find it, except slightly in the last post before mine, which touched on that Martinez was "thicker"........Several others also said that Martinez was the biggest, but gave no logical reasons. Not logical to me anyway.

These are the facts as I have been able to find them.

Martinez is the bigger, Margarito is next, and Oscar is the smallest.

My reasoning; Laszlo Papp began as an amateur welter and fought as a pro middle. He was 5'5" tall. but he was stocky and broad shouldered and full of muscle.

There are thousands of other examples. how do you think that Paul Williams can fight as a middleweight and as a welterweight when he is ..what..about 6'1" or 6' 2",

The big secret is the skeleton, the frame, the weight and density of the bones, the shape or broadness of the skeleton which governs just how much solid muscle it can carry.

Oscar began as a 130lb'er, as low as 128. His bones are lighter and of smaller circumference. There's no contest here.

Martinez began as a welterweight, obviously has heavier bones and is broader than Oscar, can carry more muscle, and could NEVER in anyone's wildest dreams to be imagined as ever being 130 like Oscar.

Margarito, began as a lightweight, well inside the limit, but he was only still aged 15, and still growing., so we can say that he was a welterweight, which he soon became as he grew.

There is only about a half-an-inch difference in height between each from Margarito down to Martinez, and height anyway MAKES NO DIFFERENCE.

Martinez is the BIGGEST of the three, Margarito is next and Oscar is the smallest.

Oh boy!

HA! I believe that my avatar pic proves that Manny is the biggest amongst all of them!









totally kidding.