Since we're on the subject. Better Resume Floyd or Roy?

[Southpawkiller]

Funny how alot of the same people in this Forum now discredit Floyds victory over Mosely when there was thread after thread from the Floyd haters saying that Mosley would knock him out, that Floyd was afraid to fight him, that the fight would never happen.

Its pathetic.

Floyd has a great resume. Excpet for Marquez (tune up), his last 3 fights have been against legit World champions who held or once held titles at the 147 limit or higher.

[Toney616]

I'm going with Floyd:
Comparing wins:
Jose Luis Castillo < Toney
Jose Luis Castillo=Green Hopkins
Oscar De La Hoya=Ruiz
Shane Mosley=Virgil Hill
Zab Judah=Harding
Diego Corrales>Griffin
Ricky Hatton < Tarver

Noticable losses:
Tarver ko loss
Johnson ko loss
Tarver ud loss

Accomplishments:
Title defenses don't really mean much these days
5 division world champion > 4 division world champion

[Southpawkiller]

I'm going with Floyd:
Comparing wins:
Jose Luis Castillo < Toney
Jose Luis Castillo=Green Hopkins
Oscar De La Hoya=Ruiz
Shane Mosley=Virgil Hill
Zab Judah=Harding
Diego Corrales>Griffin
Ricky Hatton
Noticable losses:
Tarver ko loss
Johnson ko loss
Tarver ud loss

Accomplishments:
Title defenses don't really mean much these days
5 division world champion > 4 division world champion

I fear a major backlash for you saying castillo was greater than Toney...

[Toney616]

I fear a major backlash for you saying castillo was greater than Toney...

Where did I state that?

Jose Luis Castillo < Toney

[RubenSonny]

I fear a major backlash for you saying castillo was greater than Toney...

Lucky he didn't say that then........

[Toney616]

Lucky he didn't say that then........

[Southpawkiller]

Sorry dude misread the sign....

I was discrediting ur opinion, i could just imagine the bashin u wud get off sum ppl for sayin it, if u had said it!

[Toney616]

Sorry dude misread the sign....

no problemo

[IMDAZED]

Roy by a healthy margin.

[Walt Liquor]

I'm going with Floyd:
Comparing wins:
Jose Luis Castillo < Toney
Jose Luis Castillo=Green Hopkins
Oscar De La Hoya=Ruiz
Shane Mosley=Virgil Hill
Zab Judah=Harding
Diego Corrales>Griffin
Ricky Hatton < Tarver

Noticable losses:
Tarver ko loss
Johnson ko loss
Tarver ud loss

Accomplishments:
Title defenses don't really mean much these days
5 division world champion > 4 division world champion

title defenses don't mean much????????? wtf are you talking about???

and the bold is just not right. dela was a good 5 yrs past his prime. mosley was a good win, but he was definitely old and inactive. (unlike v hill)

zab at 140 maybe. zab got slapped arond by everyone at 147, including tata. and not by spinks once.