Malignaggi vs Cotto an upgrade over Winky vs Macklin??

[Southpawology]

Do you guys think paulie vs cotto is an upgrade over the winky vs macklin fight for the maidana/morales card???

[goblin213]

This card should be on Solo Boxeo.

[Silencers]

In terms of action Malignaggi vs Cotto might be better but in terms of significance it isn't an upgrade at all, Macklin wouldn't be too far off to a title shot if he keeps winning and Winky might get himself back into the title picture if he had won the fight. It was a more significant fight than an ex-junior welterweight titlist fighting a blown up lightweight at welterweight.

[Pullcounter]

Do you guys think paulie vs cotto is an upgrade over the winky vs macklin fight for the maidana/morales card???

it is not an improvement

[Rockin']

Paulie could give Cotto alot of trouble. While he won't knock Cotto out by any stretch of the imagination he could out box him. I think that is a pretty interesting match up...........Rockin'