Ruiz, Byrd, Rahman are top 3 HWs

[S0UTHPAW]

Ok lets take the top guys and see who "should" beat who if they fought tomorrow.
VK BEATS : ALL

Byrd BEATS : Brewster, Peter, Ruiz, and maybe Toney
Byrd LOSES : Wlad, VK

Brewster BEATS : Ruiz, Peter, possible Wlad
Brewster LOSES : VK, Toney, Byrd, more than likely Wlad

Peter BEATS : Ruiz.......
Peter LOSES : Everyone else

Wlad BEATS : Ruiz, Toney, Byrd, Peter, Possible Brewster
Wlad LOSES : VK (aint gonna happen)

Ruiz BEATS : HAHAHAHA>>>>
Ruiz LOSES : Everyone, unless it goes to the judges

Toney BEATS : Ruiz, Peter, Brewster
Toney LOSES : VK, Wlad, Byrd


A few of these fights could go either way, so who knows what the top list should look like

[Leo Pradun]

vitali
brewster
wlad

[RAESAAD]

I don't even think Ruiz is top 10 but top 5 for me I would have to say VK,Bryd,Brewster,Toney,Rahman.

[BAREKNUCKLES]

Vitali Klitschko is the only fighter that I can think of that has proven anything in championship fights up to this point.

Samuel Peter is up and coming, and could quite possibly be the real deal.

However, I remember before Wladimir was demolished by Corey Sanders, that he was the talk of the town and unstoppable. Now, he is just a big, fragile fighter.

Ruiz is dismissed because he's illigitimate. He seems to operate in bought-off and corrupt affairs, otherwise he would have alot of losses to guys like Golotta, and it was very obvious that he couldn't handle even James Toney.

Chris Byrd is a joke. He beat Jameel McCline, whooppee-doo. I thought he lost to Golotta also. He's just not a heavyweight, and on top of that, he's annoying to watch and boring.

As far as Lamon Brewster goes, he's a 2nd tier heavyweight along with McBride and even Rahman, he is severly lacking in skills. It wasn't that long ago that old man Holyfield beat him up.

Audley is legitimate, Sam Peter seems to be, Wladimir could be back on top if he doesn't go to sleep, but the rest of them are just there to rake in a few bucks. I wish they would all leave the heavyweight division.

Vitali Klitschko is the linear champion, passed down from Lennox Lewis.

I think that the championship lineage should be followed from days of old to name the champion.

Until somebody beats up Vitali, and it could happen, but until it does he's the champion and let's say that there are a couple of contenders and the rest are pretenders.

As for James Toney. I think James Toney, on a good day can beat anyone if he's in shape. I think they should designate him to beat up all of the pretenders in the division. Once he beats Byrd, Ruiz (again), Rahman, and all the rest of the rif-raf, I say give him a title shot. He deserves it just for being so old-school and tough.

Knuckles.

[adp023]

reluctantly mine are:

1. Vitali
2. Toney
3. Byrd

how sad is that? there is absolutely no hope for HW boxing. i mean...Mercer vs. Briggs PPV...just proves my point!

[Renegade]

1. VK
2. Toney
3. Brewster/Byrd/Ruiz

Let DK's boys fight it out for #3.