Comments Thread For: Sergio's Destruction of Paul Williams Demotes Mayweather

[LeadUppercut]

If Floyd were to Fight sergio who would you favor. I would favor Sergio.

They fight in different divisions, P4P assumes that all things are equal.

[LeadUppercut]

i thought a Floyd vs Martinez fight would be a toss up at 54, but it's clear Sergio can't make 54 anymore and he's actually a true MW. he is too big for Floyd who is a small welterweight despite what some clowns want to tell you. Manny is also too small for Sergio, who was fast and powerful even though he had to come down in weight so quickly and drop the extra 2 pounds.

You would have to favour Martinez over both Floyd and Manny.

I agree. Marley is correct. Neither Manny nor Floyd should be expected to go up two weight divisions to fight Martinez.

[periks19]

Lol this writer marley is a disgrace to boxing writting he makes sense on martinez demoting pbf but pacquiao as well. First #1 should be martinez at #2 should be pbf #3 pacquiao how the hell in the world a win against margarito more impressive than the win pbf had against mosley seriously i would like to hear marleys argument on that why is a margarito win is better than a mosley win at the time pbf fought mosley he was the #1 ww.

Martinez in one night has faced way better comp than pac has his last 5 fights. I mean when pac kod hatton marley other writers of pac went crazy it took manny more than one shot to finally put already beaten and already stopped hatton to sleep martinez with one shot put williams to sleep a guy that never before got stopped and only got dropped once and guess who was the one that drop him the first time martinez. I mean marley u are putting pac in front of martinez but williams beat a prime margarito pac beat a damage margarito really u think that was impressive how did u get ur job as a boxing writer by being biad???

[LeadUppercut]

I just caught up......

You guys put WAY TOO MUCH importance on theoretical P4P rankings.

But even though I do not rate theoretical P4P rankings over far more important things like divisional supremacy and actual tangible accomplishments, I can see that a lot of posters have no idea what criteria is even considered when evaluating P4P status.

The point is.....
we are encumbered with a ****ty corrupt system in the ABC sanctioning bodies, and now you guys wanna further complicate the issue by rating P4P rankings over actual achievements?

*** P4P, it's meaningless.

And *** the ABC circus, it's almost as bad.

And to be honest, the lineal "title" doesn't mean **** either.

If all of the belts disappeared tomorrow, would anybody still doubt that Martinez is the man at 160?

[fast_knuckles]

[Dan Gutierrez]

Now Floyd Maywather Jr. and the Mayweather family got to think of other excuses now that chicken Floyd's name was mentioned by Sergio Martinez for a potential dance partner.

[Great Afrikan]

Sergio Martinez is P4P #1....He beat Kelly Pavlik at his own weight and just demolished PWill who demanded a catchweight.

Pac looks for every advantage when facing competition and Mayweather's on vacation.

[bluetuazon]

lfc19titles. are you dumb?can you read the question? your ****** response does'nt explain why mayweather is om the list.if he has'nt accomplished anything like you said then why is he on the list ******? going to number 3 is garbage. he should'nt be there on accomplishments. is it because he's the man?

he is the man yes..he is the man who has a court case for beating up women....he is the man yes...a man on vacation...until he comes backk..stfu!!!

[bluetuazon]

this ***** like martinez. i actually think he's the only one out there that can take mayweather out. not lady-boy pac. not cotto, not berto,nor angulo. martinez vs mayweather is the real fight.

and you wish that floyd would come out and fight him huh?? dude..ull be dissapointed....seriously...

[bluetuazon]

True boxing fans can't argue this.

whats up with true boxing fans vs boxing fans debate....arent we watching the same sport?? or are you watching something else??