Which of these guys deserves HOF consideration more? Miguel Cotto or Glen Johnson?

[Story]

between iceta and chicano aka cotto is not a good guy he cheats on his wife thread

you guys are trolls and i would love to get 12 rounds with anyone of you

by the way where is the option where i could pick both

Doing 12 rds even while winning a fight is torture bro lol.

[-Kev-]

Roy Jones Jr, Antonio Tarver, Clinton Woods, Montell Griffin, Eric Harding, Yusaf Mack, and Richard Hall.

vs

Paulie Malignaggi, Shane Mosley, Zab Judah, Carlos Quintana, Joshua Clottey, Yuri Foreman.

[-Kev-]

Doing 12 rds even while winning a fight is torture bro lol.

Lol he has to be a pro boxer.

Amateur's go 4 rounds and are tired as hell.

I think he meant 12 one minute rounds, which equal to 4 three minute rounds.

[craigus1990]

glen and it aint close...

[Check]

Seriously.....Iceta you are better than this. Stop handing out props to guys that are simply game.

[Franco2012]

Johnson for me and it's not even close. And I don't think either guy should make it to the HOF.

Wins over:
Tarver
Jones
Harding
Reggie Johnson
Montell Griffin

Controversial losses to Woods, Dawson, Gonzales, Ottke, and Cloud.

Johnson's resume ****s on Cotto's.

All the titles Johnson won weren't vacant either.

First of all he won only 1 title,not titles.

And second that was VACANT title!

[Check]

Watch the Roy Jones fans flood this page and start claiming Glen as a great fighter because their boy got the stretcher treatment from him. Face it, as soon as Roys prime diminished he was an awful fighter.

[Mr. Fantastic]

between iceta and chicano aka cotto is not a good guy he cheats on his wife thread

you guys are trolls and i would love to get 12 rounds with anyone of you

by the way where is the option where i could pick both

Ok ethug.

[Iceta Lives]

Johnson is taking Cloud and Dawson to hell and back while Cotto is fighting Foreman and Chavez Jr and Johnson is a grandfather compared to Miguel. Lol. I figured maybe the Cotto stans would come crawling out of their rat holes in this thread. And little do we know, here they are voting for Cotto.

[Iceta Lives]

Roy Jones Jr, Antonio Tarver, Clinton Woods, Montell Griffin, Eric Harding, Yusaf Mack, and Richard Hall.

vs

Paulie Malignaggi, Shane Mosley, Zab Judah, Carlos Quintana, Joshua Clottey, Yuri Foreman.

All the guys above are better fighters than the ones listed below other than maybe swapping around a couple names. Glen Johnson has better wins on his resume than Cotto. Plain and simple. Tarver and Griffin are better than Clottey, Quintana, and Foreman. The only comparable guys on the list are Jones and Mosley and granted, Jones had just been KOd by Tarver so I guess beating Mosley controversially is a tad better. Lol.