Comments Thread For: Mayweather is Back: BScene’s Pound for Pound Top Ten

[Laborer]

the reality

oh, thanks for pointing out 'the' as the only reason i had it all wrong. thanks mr english teacher, why don't you go back to your classroom and play boss!

[Laborer]

LOLzzz

*****s are happy now that boxingscene put KFC as #1 P4P... its very funny anyway...

but the reality will not be forgotten that Pac in the Fighter of the Decade, Fighter of the year, so let KFC take the P4P #1 for now for his consolation price by beating mosley. I give credit to that win....

But Pac is the one put against KFC He has no chance he can win a single round.

'fighter of the decade' has nothing to do with anything 2010. your decade was sooo last year!

[royjonesjrKTFO]

Floyd have always been no.1 until he loses, Manny is the default P4P no.1. Floyd let him borrow his crown while he took a vacation. Now the all-around better boxer/fighter have taken it back. Manny lost to an Erik Morales on the decline and struggled two times against Juan M. Marquez, indicating Manny is unable to make adjustments.

Floyd Mayweather does just about everything better than Manny Pacquiao in the ring.

[royjonesjrKTFO]

Alot of you people don't know the real meaning of Pound4Pound, btw.

Also, Paul is NOT better than Chad. Paul ain't got no defense.

[lb.4lb.]

LOL.... Floyd is #1 lb 4 lb for UD'ing a 36yo bloated featherweight and a 38yo Moseley. WOW! C'mon now.. Sure you could say Cotto had to shave 2 lbs., but Pacquiao fought them at their primes in their best weight classes! And i'd say Pacquiao also dominated his last 2 fights moreso than Mayweather did. Pacquiao deserves the #1 spot, and i doubt the official ring rankings won't demote him to #2.

[Epie2]

If Floyd was not an American, Boxingscene would not have made him P4P #1 coming from #2 by merely beating an old #3 who was beaten by Cotto.

[Tweezy316]

*******s are pissed!!! lol look if you wanna call pac p4p #1 then you HAVE to respect the rankings. JMM was the #2 p4p fighter in the world regardless of age. Shane Mosley was the #3 p4p fighter regardless of age. Floyd came out of almost a 2 year retirement and fought both of them and only lost 1 round out of 24. That is very dominant. KO's can be lucky dominating a fighter there is nothing lucky about that. Those wins are more impressive than cotto and clottey. Floyd was #1 before he retired Pacquiao NEVER beat Floyd so I don't understand the argument that Pac is #1 until he loses. Even if he's fighter lesser competition? You guys talk about JMM and Shane Mosley's age. Well if they are soo old and past their prime why did Pacquiao avoid a 3rd fight with Marquez and duck Mosley in front of the whole world?

[GRUSTLER]

Oh dang. The *******s are now going to go on a red-k rampage on BScene lol........ BScene forum second to none!!!!

I agree! After the Mayweather/Mosley fight. They went in on me.
Formed an alliance to get me in the red because the truth was too
much for them to handle! BUT there is NO stopping the fact that
Floyd is the real P4P#1, before he left and now that he is back.
I see that in the article they said Pac/Cotto could have the edge
on May/Mosley. BUT what makes Shane Mosley a greater win in
my opinion is that Shane unlike Cotto, won all of his titles, Cotto
has always been the king of vacant straps. PLUS, Mosley KO'd
Margarito, who KO'd an UNDEFEATED Cotto and took his title and
Mosley took the title from Margarito.

[BennyST]

So JMM is still number 6, but Mosley drops out of the top 20?

Marquez was a little FW moving up, and as old as Mosley in boxing years, to WW. Mosley was the bigger guy in reality than Floyd and lost in as bad a performance as Marquez.

His previous years of performances are also better than Mosley's.

[invincible_pac]

Pacquiao force Mayweather to fight the best available opposition out there.

(Remember before Mayweather agree to fight Mosley, he was thinking about fighting Saul Alvarez or The great Mathew HAtton.)

In return showing his true phenomenal skills possibly surpassing Pacquiao at this point.

So him being number is not a problem, or you can say a tie maybe.

The two should fight nothing else is acceptable!

Thats the only way to end the debate of who is the best!!!