Andre Berto vs. Devon Alexander

[etlux]

Who wins?

Berto got a UD against Urango. Alexander destroyed Urango. (just to analyze common opponents, not to extol triangle theory)

[heat27]

Devon Alexander

[fallen9182]

Alexander by decision

[jrosales13]

Until I see Alexander at WW, I have to go with Berto...

[Siggy]

alexander in a blow out. he'd jab the sht out of berto and keep turning him like a good boxer should. berto would just be swinging and grabbing at air the whole fight.
alexander by a WIDE UD, if he doesnt stop him earlier.

[.Sakuragi.]

Until I see Alexander at WW, I have to go with Berto...

I agree, at 140 Devon wins a UD. But at 147? I would say Berto has a little edge

[BG_Knocc_Out]

If feather-fisted Quintana and Collazo could hurt Berto, I'd give Alexander a good shot. I think it more or less depends on how well Alexander can compete at welterweight, seeing as how that's probably where the fight would end up.

[SoldierWarrior]

Triangle theories don't work but I believe Devon Alexander is so much more talented then Al Haymon's puppet Berto. Alexander by beautiful KO.

[Hi-Dro]

alexander in a blow out. he'd jab the sht out of berto and keep turning him like a good boxer should. berto would just be swinging and grabbing at air the whole fight.
alexander by a WIDE UD, if he doesnt stop him earlier.

Yes I agree with your analysis, yet urango shouldn't be a measuring stick for who wins, but I think that Alexander has the skills, and ability to outbox the **** out of Andre Berto. Berto is a strong dude though, so I'd wonder how Alexander would take his power, but I'd give him the benefit of the doubt.

[Heeb]

P4P Alexander is better. However, Berto could never make 140 and I don't know how Alexander would preform at 147. I'm gonna guess Alexander gets the UD.