If Froch Won The Super 6 And Remained Undefeated, Would He Be A Greater SM than Joe

[Fighting Spirit]

Calzaghe. If Froch won the super 6 and remanied undefeated, would he be a greater Super Middlweight than Joe Calzaghe?

[Jim Jeffries]

Well he's off to a bad start.

Most people thought he lost to Dirrell.

[FLYBOY]

Crotch already lost to Dirrell.

[YoungJab]

Crotch already lost to Dirrell.

a rematch with dirrel after super 6 should be lined up if dirrel doesnt get knockedout in the process

[P.WILL]

Well he beat Taylor, he "beat" Dirrell, he would have to beat Kessler, beat Arthur Abraham, after that its the semis I think right?
But yes, imo he would be a greater 168 lber

[Squirrel]

If he got through the entire Super6 undefeated then yeah, he'd be greater than Joe quite easily tbh.

That level of competition, consistently, on opponents home-turf, at this stage in his career, *****s Joes "0".

[Pullcounter]

calz never fought anyone half as good as all the peeps in the super 6

[Jim Jeffries]

Well he beat Taylor, he "beat" Dirrell, he would have to beat Kessler, beat Arthur Abraham, after that its the semis I think right?
But yes, imo he would be a greater 168 lber

What are Taylor's credentials at 168?

Shot Lacy? The same Lacy shot Roy destroyed?

[Sweet Jesus]

He'd be greater period.

[FloydTBE]

In my opinion yes he would, going by the oposition that both guys would have faced yes definatley froch would be greater than JC.