Which fight was Closer? Oscar-Floyd or Mosley-Cotto?

[norrin]

I would say Cotto-Mosely. I looked at the compu box numbers DLH and Mayweather and DLH was clearly outboxed.

[El Chicano]

Floyd vs. Oscar was the easier fight to score. In some of the early and middle rounds Oscar does some good work but he tires in the end. Oscar worked and landed more in the rounds he won. I had it 7-5 for Floyd last time i watched it. Had it even goingt into the 11th.

Cotto vs. Mosley was much harder to score, many rounds where very even both in output and landed punches, booth guys coming to fight. In the late rounds Cotto moves and boxes while Mosley showes an effective offensive. I had it 115-113 for Cotto as i remember but i can easily see how some of the even rounds could have been scored for Mosley instead. Neither guy dominated any round, all rounds where hard and even.

Cotto-Mosley was the closer fight.

So you picked Cotto-Mosley because you had it "115-113", while you had Oscar-Floyd "7-5"?

115-113 is the same as 7-5 you Dodo

[-Boxzilla-]

hands down cotto mosley ...

[warp1432]

Both fights had obvious winners, but Cotto Mosley had closer rounds.

[bdevils]

Mosley-Cotto easy. Floyd should of won by UD not SD

[RULE]

Cotto-Mosley

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Floyd vs Oscar was 9 rounds to 3, 8 rounds to 4 at best. Not even close.

Cotto vs Mosley was close but clear 7-5 win for Cotto.

[Sweet Jesus]

This is a hard one, I can't decide.

BoxingScene decided for you.

[2120]

This is a hard one, I can't decide.

cotto and mosely was a close and entertaining fight

floyd fight with oscar was not close at all but it was another example of floyd risking nothing and just content on winning a dec. the other two examples would be his fights with Marquez and baldo.

at 147 and above floyd is overly cautious but even with doing very little floyd fight with oscar was not close

[El Chicano]

FACTS


Mosley vs Cotto: 116-113, 115-113 twice, all in favor of Miguel (UD)

Oscar vs Floyd: 115-113 for DLH; 116-112 & 115-113 for Duck (SD)