Zab Judah, Carlos Quintana and Luis Collazo

[boxasmash]

Rank them 1-3 at Welterweight. All similar sized southpaws,all fringe contenders now they've been beaten by the best. How do they fair versus eachother?

Zab Judah - Only Undisputed champion of the bunch, had fairly close fights with Mayweather and Cotto. Impressed me in his loss to Clottey recently (even though he did lose).

Carlos Quintana - Has the biggest win of the three in Paul Williams although he lost the rematch. I can't see Zab or Collazo beating P.Will. He got beat up vs Cotto whereas Zab gave him a close-ish fight. Former WBO champion

Luis Collazo - Former WBA Welterweight champ, beaten handidly by Shane Mosley but will be remembered for the Hatton and Berto loses which could have easily gone the other way. Both very close fights which he could have won.

Please rank them on head to head, how you think they'd do against eachother and not on resume.


My rankings
1. Carlos Quintana
2. Zab Judah
3. Luis Collazo

Was pretty tough to rank, not much between them at all, a few years back I'd put Zab #1 but not right now.

[Sicario]

1- Quintana

2- Collazo

3- Judah

[DLT]

What kind of rankings are these? Do you want us to rank them how they should be ranked going by what they have done or do you want us to rank them by who we think the best fighters really are at that weight? I think Collazo is the best guy at WW, I think Zab is the most talented, and I think Quintana has the biggest win

[boxasmash]

What kind of rankings are these? Do you want us to rank them how they should be ranked going by what they have done or do you want us to rank them by who we think the best fighters really are at that weight?

How you think they'd do against eachother, who the best of the three is basically. Forget resumes.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Quintana
Collazo
Judah


Judah is more talented than Quintana and Collazo ut only for 3 or 4 rounds!!

[Pugilistic™]

1. Carlos Quintana
2. Luis Collazo
3. Zab Judah

[DLT]

I think Collazo is the best guy at WW, I think Zab is the most talented, and I think Quintana has the biggest win

[Junito-Rulez]

1) Quintana
2) Collazo
3) Judah

[Pullcounter]

according to size:

1. quintana
2. collazo
3. judah

according to skills:

1. judah
2. quintana
3. collazo

according to chin

1. collazo
2. quintana
3. judah

[egreezy]

according to size:

1. quintana
2. collazo
3. judah

according to skills:

1. judah
2. quintana
3. collazo

according to chin

1. collazo
2. quintana
3. judah

I think Judah has a better chin than Quintana