Joe Calzaghe = One Of The Best Boxers Ever

[Fat Bloke]

lol at you PATHETIC Calzaghe nuthuggers who thinks he is an ATG.

Why do you think Calzaghe is a top 20 of all time? plz explain to me. It can't be because of his resume(coz it ****in blows) so it must be because he is undeafeted right? Well theres plenty of undeafeted fighters out there. Sven Ottke like I meantioned earlier had 21 title defences and retired undeafeted like slappy did so I guess he is an ATG to? Or what about JCC Jr a legend right? Zsolt Erdei is also one of the best of all time right?

typical ****** ****

[Hyde]

typical ****** ****

Ok fine if I'm a ****** **** then you should have no trouble answering my question. What makes Joe Calzaghe an ATG? His resume(even tough it is horrible)? Because he is undeafeted(even tough guys like erdei and ottke are also undeafeted)? Or what? WHAT THE **** MAKES SLAPPY AN ATG?

[VipersThunder]

This thread should be removed, Calzaghe sucks....

[-Swizzy-]

typical ****** ****

how about you make at least 1 intelligent post to prove your point instead of making statements and insults. give a detailed explanation as to why you think calzaghe should be ranked that high.

[Holliday]

top 20 great,yeagh right

[Blue Heffner]

calzhage should be top 10 all time.his win over bernard is very underated.i only fight he might should have took was glen johnson.

You are crazy, just literally crazy!

Calzaghe is the most overrated fighter of all time. He was a FRAUD and a JOKE. He doesn't even belong in the top 100 of all time.

His resume is ****in wack.

Roy Jones Jr(40 years old and totally shot)
Bernard Hopkins(44 years old and past prime yet he still arguably beat Calzaghe)
Jeff Lacy(an overhyped C level fighter)
Mikkel Kessler(another overhyped C level fighter who got whooped way worse by a green 25 year old Andre Ward)
Chris Eubank(weight drained and past prime)

WHAT A ****IN JOKE.

and Mikkel Kessler was supposed to be his best and most career defining win. LMFAO... all time greats don't have guys on the level of Kessler as their best win. thats ****in pathetic.

He defended a ****ty WBO paper title in his own backyard against bums for 10 years before finally going up to light heavy and beating two shot 40+ year old legends. He was AFRAID to go to america earlier and fight a PRIME Roy Jones Jr, PRIME Bernard Hopkins or Antonio Tarver, Glen Johnson, Chad Dawson. And there's a damn good reason for that... he knows he would have gotten his ass whooped.


If Joe Calzaghe had one loss he would not even be talked about nearly as much. He got two razor thin split decisons against Robin Reid and Bernard Hopkins, if those where losses Calzaghe would be nothing. Without that "0" Joe is NOTHING. His whole legacy(if you can call it that) is built on being undeafeted...

Being undeafeted means NOTHING when you have such a ****ty resume like Calzaghe does.

Joe Calzaghe was no better than Sven Ottke. Sven had 21 title defences and retired undeafeted just like Calzaghe so I guess he is an ATG to right? hahahahahahhahaha LMFAO.

Both a PRIME Roy Jones Jr and a PRIME Bernard Hopkins would have SCHOOLED Calzaghe.

He got a razor thin split decision against a past prime 44 year old Bernard Hopkins, and in my and many others oppinion he should have lost that fight. a PRIME Hopkins would have knocked him out.

A totally shot 40 year old RJJ knocked him down and had him seriously hurt in the first round, a PRIME Roy would have ended it right there.

In a few years Calzaghe will be forgotten outside of Wales. Nobody in america has heard of him... not even in mainland Europe is Calzaghe famous...

Joe Calzaghe was a COWARD and a FRAUD and also a bad rolemodel for kids. Cowards like Calzaghe are not good rolemodels.

Joe Calzaghe also has one of the most ugliest styles of all time. He couldn't throw a real punch to save his life... His slapping style is pathetic. It looks worse than a female fighter. Holly Holm the female welterweight champion punches harder than Slapzaghe guaranteed.

Joe Calzaghe is an absolute DISGRACE to boxing.

Yes he is, a straight bum.

[Fat Bloke]

Top 20 winning. doesn't suprise me.

Joe Calzaghe is one of the finest boxers ever.

[Hyde]

Top 20 winning. doesn't suprise me.

Joe Calzaghe is one of the finest boxers ever.

This poll is a joke and you know it.

And no, Joke Calzaghe is not one of the finest boxers ever. It's an absolute disgrace to mention him in the same sentence as real ATG's like Sugar Ray Robinson, Muhammad Ali, Ray Leonard etc etc.

[VipersThunder]

Carnivore(aka Tunney) again proves what a ****in joke he is. He is the most biased poster on here without a doubt.

He nutthugs european fighters ridicilously much.

Calzaghe a top 20 ATG? LMFAO.

I'd really like to see your ATG list Carnivore.

Let me Guess it looks something like this right?

1. Wladimir Klitschko
2. Vitali Klitschko
3. Joe Calzaghe
4. Sven Ottke
5. Zsolt Erdei
6. Nikolai Valuev
7. Mikkell Kessler
8. Tomazs Adamek
9. Felix Sturm
10. Muhammad Ali(oops j/k ali is black so he is not even top 100, your real numeber 10 is probably Sebastian Sylvester or some other random tall white european fighter amirite?)

Carnivore is a racist son of a ***** who hates black american people. true story.

Who put you in the red oasis ***? Report him to the mods. He is a mod so you can't put him on ignore. But he can still neg you. It's total bull****. That guy is the biggest wanna be Calzaghe ass ***er on the planet. The guy would name his kids after Joe if it was possible for the gay **********s he plows to have kids.

[Sick/]

Who put you in the red oasis ***? Report him to the mods. He is a mod so you can't put him on ignore. But he can still neg you. It's total bull****. That guy is the biggest wanna be Calzaghe ass ***er on the planet. The guy would name his kids after Joe if it was possible for the gay **********s he plows to have kids.

Carry on crying you little turd