Comments Thread For: BoxingScene Female Fight of the Year: Katie Taylor-Amanda Serrano II

[BoxingUpdates]

Sometimes, this job is too easy. Selecting the Female Fight of the Year for 2024 is one of those times, so you shouldnt be surprised that this award goes to Novembers rematch between Katie Taylor and Amanda Serrano.
[Click Here To Read More]

[JeBron Lamez]

Such a great fight.

[BlackRobb]

Serrano was robbed. Again. This one worse than the first robbery.

[r.burgundy]

1 of the absolute worst robberies I've ever seen in boxing and easily the worst robbery on the women's side and also some of the worst refereeing.

amanda needed a k.o just to get a draw lol

[ODLH Chicano Goat]

Great fight, horrendous decision. Serrano wasn't the only one robbed that night, the fans were robbed of an epic trilogy.

[pad]

It's obvious that Serrano much talked about power doesn't translate to anything over 130. She's had 20 rounds with Katie and if you were kind you could say Serrano won 8 rounds in the two fights. Taylor is just too good at 135 and 140. Probably the greatest ever female fighter. Serrano and her team would do with less complaining and put some respect on Katie Taylor name. Serrano is the best at 130 or lower but even she has to admit that Katie is the world's best at 135 to 140. I would like to see a more humble person from Serrano in 2025. They're is no shame in losing twice to probably the greatest ever female fighter in Katie. As for that lowlife of a trainer. Pure scumbag of a person the way he behaves. Katie made the whole family rich. They would be wise to remember that.

[Left Hook Louie]

I like Serrano. She's a real warrior.
Too bad she laughs like a horse.
I know that sounds mean but it freaks me out a little.

[joseph5620]

It's obvious that Serrano much talked about power doesn't translate to anything over 130. She's had 20 rounds with Katie and if you were kind you could say Serrano won 8 rounds in the two fights. Taylor is just too good at 135 and 140. Probably the greatest ever female fighter. Serrano and her team would do with less complaining and put some respect on Katie Taylor name. Serrano is the best at 130 or lower but even she has to admit that Katie is the world's best at 135 to 140. I would like to see a more humble person from Serrano in 2025. They're is no shame in losing twice to probably the greatest ever female fighter in Katie. As for that lowlife of a trainer. Pure scumbag of a person the way he behaves. Katie made the whole family rich. They would be wise to remember that.

I'm being kind by only saying that you clearly have no idea how to score a fight. That's beyond ridiculous and can't be seen as anything other than fan bias. It's clear from your post that seems to focus on personalities and your likes and dislikes. Nothing wrong with that. Just don't pretend that you're being objective because you're clearly not.

[BirdSong]

serrano starts off fast v katie but loses steam towards the end in the2 fights, great fights tho and i think serrano takes the next one if it happens

[pad]

What most on some of these threads struggle with is their preset bias for a fighter before a fight even starts. If I had a dollar for Everytime someone has told me Serrano definitely had to have won the first fight because she won the 5th round. It's embarrassing when you reply to them how did the other 9 rounds pan out. In order to score female boxing especially. You must score 10 fights rolled into 1 fight. Taylor has Serrano number because she knows how to win rounds every time she fights. Bar the loss to Cameron. Serrano strategy was to win with power, when after 3 or 4 rounds of the first fight it became apparent that Taylor has a granite chin Serrano and her corner had no plan B. I would blame that corner she has who should have immediately changed their whole strategy and try and win enough rounds too get the win. Katie has the knowledge from her amateur career on how to win or nick close rounds. If they fight again it will be 3-0 to Katie unless Serrano changes her corner. You can't knock out Katie Taylor. She's an absolute beast and will eat any shot you give her. Actually it will be 4-0 to Katie against the Serrano sisters.