Paul Williams current P4P rank is an insult?

[fdotorres]

th same margarito that made everyones precious cotton give up!!! get out of here!! pwill is the real deal!!

are you talking about the same cotton that softened up the quintana that took away williams 0?

[Iceta]

cotto fought for a vacant title against quintana and beat him to a pulp

williams fought his first defense against quintana and lost more than convincingly. he has yet to defend a title

anser the question: how is fighting margarito hiding in the shadows? cotto didn't wait for williams to vacate the title he couldn't defend. he received an awful beating and paul vacated while he was recovering. that's not cotto's fault

let me know when paul's able to defend a title

Manny Pacquiao doesn't defend titles just like Bully said. Does that mean that he doesn't deserve his spot on the P4P list? The fight with Clottey and Williams was set, but HBO went against it. And Clottey waited until Williams was out of the division to call him out. The reason that Williams doesn't have any title defenses at 147 is just that: Cotto fighting for a vacant title belt.

[Iceta]

cotto fought for a vacant title against quintana and beat him to a pulp

williams fought his first defense against quintana and lost more than convincingly. he has yet to defend a title

anser the question: how is fighting margarito hiding in the shadows? cotto didn't wait for williams to vacate the title he couldn't defend. he received an awful beating and paul vacated while he was recovering. that's not cotto's fault

let me know when paul's able to defend a title

Paul Williams got right back in there and avenged the decision loss he suffered. Can't say the same with Cotto regarding making an attempt to get revenge on Margarito. And I give Cotto his props for destroying Quintana. It's just that he was given a title belt against Michael Jennings like Lampley said on the Clottey-Cotto telecast. You don't see Williams waiting for Pavlik to outgrow 160. Cotto is like a little hienna.

[MOTHER DUCKER]

Paul Williams got right back in there and avenged the decision loss he suffered. Can't say the same with Cotto regarding making an attempt to get revenge on Margarito. And I give Cotto his props for destroying Quintana. It's just that he was given a title belt against Michael Jennings like Lampley said on the Clottey-Cotto telecast. You don't see Williams waiting for Pavlik to outgrow 160. Cotto is like a little hienna.

Cotto is a joke but this is not to do with Cotto, its Williams and im sorry but beating Winky, Quintana and Margaritto does not equal a top tier p4p ranking. If he beats Pavlik he jumps right into the top 3 though imo..

[Iceta]

I know the Floyd ****suckers use Paul Williams as Floyd's home security system. But it's not like that with me. I hope he goes back to 154 or 147 though because there is nothing but bums at 160 other than Pavlik. Paul Williams moving up in weight is why Floyd found it safe to come out of retirement.

[fdotorres]

For fighting Michael Jennings for a vacant title. Does that answer your question? Did Williams fight for a vacant title after he lost to Quintana? NO.

no, he vacated the one he had, instead of defending it against any ranked or mandatory WW. he hasn't defended the one he has at JMW either

what's better: winning a vacant title against quintana or losing a title against quintana? heck, winning one against jennings and defending it against clottey is better than not defending the one you took away form a a champ

[fdotorres]

Paul Williams got right back in there and avenged the decision loss he suffered. Can't say the same with Cotto regarding making an attempt to get revenge on Margarito. And I give Cotto his props for destroying Quintana. It's just that he was given a title belt against Michael Jennings like Lampley said on the Clottey-Cotto telecast. You don't see Williams waiting for Pavlik to outgrow 160. Cotto is like a little hienna.

cotto had a rematch planned on july vs marg on the MSG. is it his fault that plaster was found on his gloves and he got a one year ban?

cotto's notable title defenses on WW: judah, mosley, margarito (loss), clottey

williams's notable title defenses on WW: quintana (loss)
williams's notable title defenses on JMW: none

so tell me, what ranked fighter has williams beaten? how is he underrated? above who does he deserve to be on the p4p list?

[fdotorres]

Manny Pacquiao doesn't defend titles just like Bully said. Does that mean that he doesn't deserve his spot on the P4P list? The fight with Clottey and Williams was set, but HBO went against it. And Clottey waited until Williams was out of the division to call him out. The reason that Williams doesn't have any title defenses at 147 is just that: Cotto fighting for a vacant title belt.

lol yeah, in how many weight classes has pac won belts? how many of those are ring mag belts? how many p4p fighters has he beaten?

please, don't try comparing PW to pac ever again, unless you consider beating an old, rusty winky one heck of an achievement