P4P who was greater; Lenox Lewis or Joe Calzaghe?

[Benncollinsaad]

I think calzaghe was a great boxer.... And i do think alot of people dont give him the credit he deserves...

but lewis is p4p better, just the opposition he faced were all majority at the elite level....The SMW division didnt help calzaghe...it wasnt the strongest of divisions, not his fault tho

You are forgetting one thing-Lewis got KTFO twice! Calzaghe never lost a single fight!

[larry x]

PAST PRIME Tyson and Holyfield
Headbutted Vitali
Wasted Morrison
Robbed Mercer
Overated Rahman

Calzaghe's wins:
Roy Jones
B-Hop
Kessler
Lacy
Byron Mitchell
Chris Eubank
Robin Reid
Sakio Bika

i love how you put past prime tyson and holyfield and didnt put old ass hopkins,chris"bald spot"eubanks or roy jones...lol..and i couldve sworn the uppercut causeed the cut on vitali...could you please show me the headbutt?? and robin reed????who the **** did he ever beat??

and did you put lacy on that list??

[ReadyUp]

Did this question even need to be asked??
Lennox wins include
mike tyson
holyfield
vitali
tommy morrison
ray mercer
hassem rahman
david tua

joes wins include
hopkins
roy jones jr
??????????????

I agree with Lennox as well but I put about as much stock in Lennox's win over Tyson as Joe's win over Roy. Not a whole lot.

[Pullcounter]

Who was a greater fighter period?

LL >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>. calz

[Pullcounter]

You are forgetting one thing-Lewis got KTFO twice! Calzaghe never lost a single fight!

cause calz never fought anyone good that wasn't a senior citizen and was protected by warren. (except for kessler)

[Leakbeak]

Lennox didn't avoid people like Joe did, in fact he was the one being avoided. Joe would have waited for Holyfield to take out hsi pension first

[Benncollinsaad]

i love how you put past prime tyson and holyfield and didnt put old ass hopkins,chris"bald spot"eubanks or roy jones...lol..and i couldve sworn the uppercut causeed the cut on vitali...could you please show me the headbutt?? and robin reed????who the **** did he ever beat??

and did you put lacy on that list??

Robin Reid was a first class fighter in his prime and gave Joe a very tough fight. He beat Henry Wharton, another prime British fighter and Julio Cesar Vasquez, one of the best lmws ever.

[elgaringo]

Who was a greater fighter period?

calzaghe was the better fighter tho that doesnt mean Lewis isnt in the top 5 best heavys of all time!!!

[Benncollinsaad]

Incredible how many Lewis-nuthuggers exist in this world...very depressing. You are all fuqing idiots.

[Allucard]

Lennox didn't avoid people like Joe did, in fact he was the one being avoided. Joe would have waited for Holyfield to take out hsi pension first

Didn't Calzaghe drop out of a Glen Johnson fight like 3 times, correct me if I'm wrong...