Is Pacs welterweight resume better than Floyds?

[civicvx]

Peoples forgot that Pacquiao was supposed to get killed against Hoya. I don't think Floyd has ever been in a fight where he was a 2-20 underdog. Pacquiao fighting Cotto is more than everything Mayweather has ever done in his career. He was running scared of Cotto at 147 that he had to retire when the fight was closing in.

[Doctor_Tenma]

I'll pay you bro.
I knew Floyd was gonna win.
Just wanted to bet on JMM just to jinxed him and it worked.
Just wanted to say that also. lol

You don't have to pay me. Just wanted to see if you remember, you can have it

[VERDUGO]

You don't have to pay me. Just wanted to see if you remember, you can have it

hahaha
Thanks man.

[Pullcounter]

Lets assume Pac beats Cotto. Would he have a better welterweight resume than Floyd based on this fight and the DLH fight?






Bait thread

cotto is better than any WW that floyd has fought thus far... but you can make a weak argument for floyd based on theoretical and hypothetical situations.

[Doctor_Tenma]

hahaha
Thanks man.

You can Green K me, I see that rep

[Puya]

Well....

Cotto > Judah, Marquez, Baldomir and Hatton

Less quantity.... higher quality. Take your pick.

Yup thats about it. End of Thread

[JAB5239]

Yup thats about it. End of Thread

Lets look at it a little more closely though. You really can't dismiss Baldomir. He was the lineal champ, and Zab before him. Floyd beat both those guys.

[Blue Heffner]

Absolutely not, crazy question.

[stilltharow]

so youre tellins us zab, baldomir, JMM are better welterweights than Cotto?

they must have been better at the time because they held the titles...

[Blue Heffner]

they must have been better at the time because they held the titles...

Most people are going to look at PRESENT day other than PAST and PRESENT, which makes this thread kind of irrelevant.