P4P Rankings. Based on the curent status, how do you see these rankings?

[Taino79]

Make your own top 10 in the order, because the Ring ****zine lately is giving to much credit to unactive fighters.

For Period Ended September 13, 2009
POUND-FOR-POUND Top 10
1. MANNY PACQUIAO
LIGHTWEIGHT
2. JUAN MANUEL MARQUEZ
LIGHTWEIGHT
3. BERNARD HOPKINS
LIGHT HEAVYWEIGHT
4. SHANE MOSLEY
WELTERWEIGHT
5. ISRAEL VAZQUEZ
JUNIOR FEATHERWEIGHT
6. RAFAEL MARQUEZ
JUNIOR FEATHERWEIGHT
7. NONITO DONAIRE
FLYWEIGHT
8. MIGUEL COTTO
WELTERWEIGHT
9. CELESTINO CABALLERO
JUNIOR FEATHERWEIGHT
10. PAUL WILLIAMS
MIDDLEWEIGHT/JUNIOR MIDDLEWEIGHT.

[El_Cholo]

I honestly can't believe Hopkins is still so high in the rankings.

legend yes, but he is not or should not be number 3 on that list.

[Taino79]

I honestly can't believe Hopkins is still so high in the rankings.

legend yes, but he is not or should not be number 3 on that list.

co-sign.

[MANGLER]

The inactive guys shouldn't be so high imo.

[Pullcounter]

For Period Ended September 13, 2009
POUND-FOR-POUND Top 10
1. MANNY PACQUIAO
LIGHTWEIGHT
2. JUAN MANUEL MARQUEZ
LIGHTWEIGHT
3. BERNARD HOPKINS
LIGHT HEAVYWEIGHT
4. SHANE MOSLEY
WELTERWEIGHT
5. ISRAEL VAZQUEZ
JUNIOR FEATHERWEIGHT
6. RAFAEL MARQUEZ
JUNIOR FEATHERWEIGHT
7. NONITO DONAIRE
FLYWEIGHT
8. MIGUEL COTTO
WELTERWEIGHT
9. CELESTINO CABALLERO
JUNIOR FEATHERWEIGHT
10. PAUL WILLIAMS
MIDDLEWEIGHT/JUNIOR MIDDLEWEIGHT.

I got no problem with this list, except cotto should be in front of donaire.

[cyutetrick]

yea I dont think vazquez and rafa marquez should be so high because they have been inactive for so long. But im pretty sure if they come back to old form theyll get back on the list and i feel bad for fighters like paul williams who noone wants to fight, so they can get higher on the top p4p.

[WhoreUs]

I honestly can't believe Hopkins is still so high in the rankings.

legend yes, but he is not or should not be number 3 on that list.

whenever a p4p fighter losses a couple of fights they should just have fighters come up 2 divisions to fight them.

easy win.



oh wait......hopkins did that at 160 too. never mind.

[freeloada]

Make your own top 10 in the order, because the Ring ****zine lately is giving to much credit to unactive fighters.

For Period Ended September 13, 2009
POUND-FOR-POUND Top 10
1. MANNY PACQUIAO
LIGHTWEIGHT
2. JUAN MANUEL MARQUEZ
LIGHTWEIGHT
3. BERNARD HOPKINS
LIGHT HEAVYWEIGHT
4. SHANE MOSLEY
WELTERWEIGHT
5. ISRAEL VAZQUEZ
JUNIOR FEATHERWEIGHT
6. RAFAEL MARQUEZ
JUNIOR FEATHERWEIGHT
7. NONITO DONAIRE
FLYWEIGHT
8. MIGUEL COTTO
WELTERWEIGHT
9. CELESTINO CABALLERO
JUNIOR FEATHERWEIGHT
10. PAUL WILLIAMS
MIDDLEWEIGHT/JUNIOR MIDDLEWEIGHT.

no problem with this list.. at least they dont have Paul Williams high at #3 like lame ass yahoo rankings.. ******ed.. but i have no idea why Hopkins is still that high..

[oc9979]

I think that fighters that have been inactixe longer than a year should be remove. There are still fighters that fight 3 fights a year in the p4p list. No way donaire should be ahead of cotto.
My list should be
1. Pacquiao
2. Marquez
3. Mosley
4. Cotto
5 and 6 Vitali and Wlad
7. Donaire
8. Caballero
9. William

[S A M U R A I]

Agree with the first two only. The remaining 8, I have no idea where they should be placed, they could easily be shuffled around.



| |