Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Manny Pacquiao is not top 10-30 all time...

Collapse
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
    #51
    Originally posted by The_Executioner View Post
    Even if you leave out a few of those guys we could sit here and bring up 10 more who have better resumes than Pacquiao.
    Lol nono. He's the first in boxing history to be lineal in 4 weight divisions. The talk of the town amidst the knowledgeable boxing pundits is where to place him all time. I've got a hunch he's somewhere in that range you gave. Otherwise there would be no such talk.

    Comment

      #52
      Originally posted by IMDAZED View Post
      Why wouldn't he?
      His resume doesn't hold up. His 2 best wins are Morales and Barrera. One was weight drained in the second bout and was nothing for the 3rd fight. Hatton, Marquez. Hatton decent. Marquez very good fighter. Mayweather ATG with a good not great resume.

      There are plenty fighters who have better resumes than Manny. Evander Holyfield, George Foreman, Roy Jones, the list goes on...he would surpass RJJ if he beat Floyd tho.

      Comment

        #53
        Originally posted by IMDAZED View Post
        Why wouldn't he?
        He just doesn't ok. No reason, he just doesnt

        Comment

          #54
          pac's already an all time great

          - titles in 6 divisions
          - 4 lineal championships
          - beat morales 2x
          - beat mab 2x
          - beat jmm 2x
          - 1 of 2 to Ko dlh
          - 1 of 2 to KO hatton
          - only fighter to KO morales
          - only fighter to knock down JMM 4x
          - 1 of 2 to KO mab
          - etc..

          Comment

            #55
            Originally posted by The_Executioner View Post
            His resume doesn't hold up. His 2 best wins are Morales and Barrera. One was weight drained in the second bout and was nothing for the 3rd fight. Hatton, Marquez. Hatton decent. Marquez very good fighter. Mayweather ATG with a good not great resume.

            There are plenty fighters who have better resumes than Manny. Evander Holyfield, George Foreman, Roy Jones, the list goes on...he would surpass RJJ if he beat Floyd tho.
            Why do you put saddler in the top 30 when he was beat by a man Pacquiao is considered greater than in the Philippines? If your gonna use weight drained this and that excuse. You don't make sense. You are a borderline hater. Im just glad your opinions arent what is popular. Regardless of what you think manny will end up high on the list.

            Comment

              #56
              Originally posted by The_Executioner View Post
              I aint buying it...no way does Pac move into the top 10 ALL TIME by beating Floyd Mayweather...

              So ur saying he jumps 30-40 spots by beating one man?
              put it into perspective

              ray leonard is top 10

              whitaker and monzon are considered to be around there also

              if manny beats floyd, he easily gets into top 15 for me, and if he beats a cotto or a mosley as well......then seriously dude he'll be a seven weight champ with crazy wins, he'll be a shoo in top 10

              like i said, some dont realise it yet

              Comment

                #57
                Originally posted by m00ks View Post
                Lol nono. He's the first in boxing history to be lineal in 4 weight divisions. The talk of the town amidst the knowledgeable boxing pundits is where to place him all time. I've got a hunch he's somewhere in that range you gave. Otherwise there would be no such talk.
                Enough with the weight divisions Floyd went from 130-154, facing average opposition at times. Pacquiao didn't just stock up on food and move up his body grew into it. The weightclasses business is really overrated...opponents is all that matters.

                Comment

                  #58
                  Originally posted by The_Executioner View Post
                  His resume doesn't hold up. His 2 best wins are Morales and Barrera. One was weight drained in the second bout and was nothing for the 3rd fight. Hatton, Marquez. Hatton decent. Marquez very good fighter. Mayweather ATG with a good not great resume.

                  There are plenty fighters who have better resumes than Manny. Evander Holyfield, George Foreman, Roy Jones, the list goes on...he would surpass RJJ if he beat Floyd tho.
                  no way does roy have a better res than manny

                  Comment

                    #59
                    Originally posted by LordVoldemort View Post
                    put it into perspective

                    ray leonard is top 10

                    whitaker and monzon are considered to be around there also

                    if manny beats floyd, he easily gets into top 15 for me, and if he beats a cotto or a mosley as well......then seriously dude he'll be a seven weight champ with crazy wins, he'll be a shoo in top 10

                    like i said, some dont realise it yet
                    Pernell is not near the top 10...Someone lied to you.

                    Comment

                      #60
                      Originally posted by LordVoldemort View Post
                      no way does roy have a better res than manny
                      At the moment yes he does...Prime James Toney, Hopkins, McCallum, 90's fighter of the decade, Tarver,can still beat average fighters in his late 30's...
                      Jumped around in weight jus like Pac. From 160 to heavyweight...

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      X
                      TOP