Joe Calzaghe vs. Shane Mosley

[Steak]

No, not who would win if they fought. but comparing their careers. after all, they both are about 37, both turned pro in 1993(15 years of pro experience), both have extensive amateur careers, and both are overall considered the best in their weight classes at this present time despite them being slightly past their prime.
so...

Who fought the better fighters?
Who is better at this present time?
Whos destruction over a limited(but still very good) opponent was more impressive?
Who was a better fighter in their prime?
Overall, who had the better career?

[The Surgeon]

Mosley's career pisses all over Calzaghes! Its honestly not even close, **** Joe's undefeated record it dont impress me, he'd have lost too if he had fought the caliber of fighter Mosley has done! Even Sugars last fight was better than anything Calzaghe has ever done!

[cace]

mosley all the way

[tommy boo boxer]

seriously... i dont know why i even bothered to read this thread. lol

IMO Mosely career owns Calzaghes (no disrespect to JC)

[BetterCallSaul]

Calzaghe skill, mind and boxing prowess is far beyond Mosely.

Mosely has fought the better opposistion.

[Steak]

Im pretty surprised that everyone is saying that Calzaghe's domination over Lacy was more impressive

Margarito was a 4 to 1 favorite to win the fight, considered the best fighter at 147lbs and was even on the p4p lists...and Mosley nastily knocked him out, and Margarito was widely considered impossible to knock out.

[The Surgeon]

Honestly i dont mean to offend but if anyone backs Joe over Mosley then they drop in my estimations

[The Surgeon]

Im pretty surprised that everyone is saying that Calzaghe's domination over Lacy was more impressive

Margarito was a 4 to 1 favorite to win the fight, considered the best fighter at 147lbs and was even on the p4p lists...and Mosley nastily knocked him out, and Margarito was widely considered impossible to knock out.

Lacy hadnt done ****, Marg had just walked through the divisions hardest puncher and then dismantled the number 1 guy in Cotto, its clearly a better win for Mosley Plus he scored a KO!

[Korega]

Like many said.

Sugar has fought the better opposition.
Sugar has fought in a lot more divisions.
Sugar has not been picking his opponents via cellphone text.
Sugar can brawl if need be, he takes punches a lot better than RJJ or B.hop

and lastly...he don't slap folks around like Calzaghe...He punches..and with serious devastating power, so he gonna crack Calzaghe's Sardinian chin. The only thing Calzaghe will have going for him is his speed, and Shane can match, if not outclass him as well in that dept as well.

[SHB]

Calzaghe skill, mind and boxing prowess is far beyond Mosely.

Mosely has fought the better opposistion.

Is the correct answer, and makes the poll a piece of crap really.

Who's the numpty that thinks Calzaghe doesn't brawl and can't take a punch. Jesus, where have you been? Or are you another one of these numpties who only knows what they see on HBO?