What would you give Floyd more credit for....

[adrsan84]

How is mosley ranked over williams?

Williams hasn't fought at 147 for a while, so they moved him up. I think he should stick around but he hasn't. Not to worry though, whent Tony moves to 154 Williams will have to be his target because Paul will have no problem unifying.

[Vasyl’s dad]

Look, any fight he loses he will not get as much credit. But the point is this, if he beats Hatton again, nothing happens. It wasn't the weight, it wasn't Cortez, it was the fact that Floyd was stronger, and he was even better on the inside than Ricky, what can change? Nothing.

On the other hand Tony will give him a drawn out battle no matter what, everyone knows this, your reasoning just points to the conclusion that Floyd should not take a chance, but if you think Tony is easy work then it shouldn't even be a question over who he should fight. He loses status if he loses to Tony, but he gains credit for fighting the toughest guy out there, somehting he hasn't done since 135 that has held him back from becoming the best ever.

They have more confidence in his abilities than Floyd does.

[Flawless.]

Look, any fight he loses he will not get as much credit. But the point is this, if he beats Hatton again, nothing happens. It wasn't the weight, it wasn't Cortez, it was the fact that Floyd was stronger, and he was even better on the inside than Ricky, what can change? Nothing.

On the other hand Tony will give him a drawn out battle no matter what, everyone knows this, your reasoning just points to the conclusion that Floyd should not take a chance, but if you think Tony is easy work then it shouldn't even be a question over who he should fight. He loses status if he loses to Tony, but he gains credit for fighting the toughest guy out there, somehting he hasn't done since 135 that has held him back from becoming the best ever.

I love it how easy you make it sound. When Margarito lost to Williams he was called a bum overrated and so on. The same thing will happen to Mayweather if he loses and will get zero credit. Beating Hatton at 140 is the better option than losing to anyone

[Flawless.]

Williams hasn't fought at 147 for a while, so they moved him up. I think he should stick around but he hasn't. Not to worry though, whent Tony moves to 154 Williams will have to be his target because Paul will have no problem unifying.

William stated he will fight at 147 again and 4 million offer still stands

[adrsan84]

Mayweather beat Hatton by a KO at WW, then excuses were made about weight. The fight at Jr WW would silence all doubters. But you guys think its wrong for him to fight some his same size

Margarito made Cotto quit. But it's already for Margarito to give Cotto rematch when he made him quit

I'd rather see him fight Floyd. I'd actually rather see him fight Williams too, and he would get more credit for me for that. But Cotto-Margarito was no Mayweather-Hatton, and Margarito is not retiring any time soon, so the circumstances are different.

[THE REED]

Williams hasn't fought at 147 for a while, so they moved him up. I think he should stick around but he hasn't. Not to worry though, whent Tony moves to 154 Williams will have to be his target because Paul will have no problem unifying.

he just KOed quintana in the spring? hes just had two more fights in the mean time...

[adrsan84]

he just KOed quintana in the spring? hes just had two more fights in the mean time...

I know, but that's how the ring works, he needs to stay active at the weight, he should have just fought a guy at 147, but in the long run it doesn't turn out so bad, he can be king of 154 waiting for whoever comes up.

[THE REED]

He isnt staying at 154.. hes waiting for the ww matchups to be sorted out so he can get one of them

[Flawless.]

Again how is losing better than winning

[THE REED]

Again how is losing better than winning

are you just ignoring everytime i answer this question?