Who has a better resume? Manny Pacquiao or Joe Calzaghe?

[Texanballer]

Manny Pacquiao is recognized as the p4p number 1 fighter in the world. Joe Calzaghe is recognized as the 2nd.

Who do you all think has the better overall resume?

Manny Pacquiao's four biggest wins
Juan Manuel Marquez SD 12
Marco Antonio Barrera UD 12 and TKO 11
Erik Morales KO 3 and TKO 10
Oscar Larios UD 12

Joe Calzaghe's four biggest wins
Roy Jones Jr UD 12
Bernard Hopkins SD 12
Mikkel Kessler UD 12
Jeff Lacy UD 12

[ßringer]

I don't know. I do know this though : I made a poll last night about who between Calzaghe and Pacquiao was the ultimate Senior Citizen slayer, and it went neck in neck.

[RichCCFC]

Manny Pacquiao but not by much anymore.

[BetterCallSaul]

Pacman does, but Calzaghe is undefeated and the better fighter.

[Texanballer]

assuming pacquiao losses to de la hoya i wonder if calzaghe will be p4p 1

[Flawless 2]

Pacman not even close

[ßringer]

assuming pacquiao losses to de la hoya i wonder if calzaghe will be p4p 1

Probably.

Forget the fact that Manny started at 106lbs, and is a natural 125-130lbs guy who just made his debut at 135lbs, if he's really any good he'll KO that past prime Oscar at 147 in 6 rounds. Otherwise Joe takes his spot.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

too bad manny didnt stay in philippines all throughout his prime...it would have made it a better comparison

[raabd]

Pac cause he actually beat barrera when marco wasn't over the hill yet.

[MANGLER]

Pac edges this one.