How Do you think Mayweather would do against welterweights?

[JoartCC]

First off... you're an asswipe, a ****-wad and douchebag extraordinaire, your mouth is a bucket for man-juice, your mother is a whore, you have a small-**** and compensate by roaming boxingscene forums and acting like you own it, you are a ****** transvestite who enjoys ****ing monkeys and stuffing gerbils up your ass, and on the day of your death everyone would throw a ****in parade as we stomp on your fat obese corpse. No one would miss you and there should be a federal law requiring that at least once a year a person would have to make a pilgrimage to your open grave and deficate in it. you contribute nothing to society and you fail at life in general.

my speculation is not just based on mayweather's wins against judah, baldomir and dlh. I base my assumptions on several other criteria. I also consider the natural athleticism of, ring generalship of, style match ups, and boxing ability of said fighters.

for example, floyd is a stylistic nightmare for Tito. Tito has problems against boxers. Tito was flummoxed by DLH's movement, and thoroughly outboxed by Hopkins. It is not a stretch of imagination to think that floyd should be able to out-maneuver Tito and win a decision.

These are my hypothetical answers to a hypothetical question. In no way do I assert them with any finality. Just because I say that's what would/could happen doesn't mean that's how it would play out. We can not truly know with any certitude if and how these fights would unfold.

In conclusion, even anthrax and AIDs deserve to exist more than you do, and you deserve die a horrible and painful death.

The only test of comparison by analogy is thru SAME STANDARD-SAME CRITERIA COMPARISON.

Margarito, Cotto, Williams, Mosley...

Doesnt really fit in the same category as...

Judah, Baldomir, and a shot DLH.

Of course because you are uneducated like the typical gayweather fan... you don't know of this.

You base on ring generalship, style, etc...

The same standards apply.

You dont compare a dog beating another dog by saying that same dog beats a mouse ergo...

Because you lack proper education you dont know of this.

Dont worry Ill cut you some slack.

Uneducated idiot gayweather fans are common so Im not really surprised.

The mere fact that you choose to ignore facts of his admission of cowardice, his own ducking, and *****-retiring and chose to sidesweep them by using ****** collateral arguments even proves further your lack of PROPER EDUCATION.

But no matter.

If you really prefer cowards over dignified champs... suit yourself.

Maybe if you were better educated then I think you'd think more deeply.

[Pullcounter]

The only test of comparison by analogy is thru SAME STANDARD-SAME CRITERIA COMPARISON.

we do not have the benefit of such a comparison because of floyd's early retirement that is why we must appeal to other criteria or give up the exercise entirely.

[Allucard]

I think he'd probably drop a decision to Margarito. Floyd is way too small and the physicality would be an issue I think. Floyd, to win, would have to throw many more punches than he did against other aggressive fighters -Hatton and De la Hoya, and defence is too important to him to let him throw more punches than in those fights. Floyd knew that was a bad style match. I mean, he could make Tony miss, and he would land quick, sharp punches, but over a 12 round period, constantly being chased would sap his energy. Marg would likely take a decision in my opinion.

He'd beat Shane, no question, he's quicker and smarter and fights harder, better defence, he's in his prime, I just don't see how Shane could hurt him at all.

I think he'd beat Cotto, he'd make him miss something awful and counter brutally, against Tito he'd probably outbox the 'Rican, he'd come out on top in a tough fight with Ike, Paul Williams hmmmm not sure, big physical challenge again though Floyd could pick him off like Quintana did in their first fight with counter right hands, he'd be too good for Spinks and Mayorga, and Clottey also though that'd be another physical assignment we can all ponder on.

I personally think he would edge Margarito is a what many would say boring fight but who cares, he's not coming back is he? And prime for prime i am one of the few who thinks he is better than Whitaker, who many put ahead of him for whatever reason :P

[DA1CATAS]

Honestly? I wouldn't care to see Floyd fight those guys. He gets so much flak for fighting boring fights because he DOES NOT BELONG at welter. He was a much more exciting fighter when he was fighting guys his own size. If he comes back, I hope he does so at 140.

Its not that I don't think he can't beat most of the guys you listed. Its more that I think he wouldn't get ANY credit for doing so because he would have to fight a safety first type fight. Everyone would say "Floyd won, but he just ran."

Hmmmmm.... I feel this point so I second it.. Well put.

[JoartCC]

we do not have the benefit of such a comparison because of floyd's early retirement that is why we must appeal to other criteria or give up the exercise entirely.

Then since we do not have that comparison in hand...

Get the fck out of here noob and stop comparing him to top welters when all he did was fight bums and past dudes.

Lols..

This aint even college dude.

This is just common sense.

Something your kind lacks...

[bsrizpac]

Then since we do not have that comparison in hand...

Get the fck out of here noob and stop comparing him to top welters when all he did was fight bums and past dudes.

Lols..

This aint even college dude.

This is just common sense.

Something your kind lacks...

Look at this ugly ***** trying to talk tough online. LOL!~

[KostyaTszyu44]

mayweather loses to cotto and margarito.

would lose to prime mosley,quartey and probaby trinidad too. No offense but mayweather hasnt proved **** at welter.

mate you're full of ****